I'm of the opinion that BYU needs Juniors/Seniors always starting at QB.

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 25, 2014
4:05:19pm

newey-west

I'm of the opinion that BYU needs Juniors/Seniors always starting at QB.

Is this correct?

Year	Starter		Year	Backup		Year	3rd String	Year
2014	Taysom Hill	Junior	C. Stewart	Senior	M. Hill		Fresh
2015	Taysom Hill	Senior	Trent Hosick	Soph	T. Mangum	RS
2016	Trent Hosick	Junior	T. Mangum	Fresh
2017	Trent Hosick	Senior	T. Mangum	Soph
2018	T. Mangum	Junior				
2019	T. Mangum	Senior

Report problem with this ad

newey-west

Previous username: Ninja_Kruger
New username: Random Walk
Bio page: newey-west
Joined: Sep 22, 2007
Last login: May 4, 2015
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Goodbye Hosick?

newey-west

11/25/14 10:39am

So help me, I'll stop following him on twitter!

JamesDean

11/25/14 10:41am

and miss out on his nonstop High School glory days #tbt posts?

Illegal Jimmergrant

11/25/14 10:51am

I think I will miss the music most.

JamesDean

11/25/14 10:57am

Not necessarily, they need more than 1 guy back there.

Thrill

11/25/14 10:44am

Yep, just ask USU this season or BYU with Heaps/Nelson/Lark/Munns

canadiancougar624

11/25/14 10:46am

I'm still confused about Lark and Munns, why didn't these guys develope?

bald man

11/25/14 10:51am

Why do so many of BYU's players fail to develop? It's a systemic issue that they

wabluecoug

11/25/14 10:53am

I have no clue. Maybe they did develop and just weren't that good. I dont' know.

bald man

11/25/14 11:00am

Not necessarily. Even Elite 11 QB recruits are 50/50 at best.

Thrill

11/25/14 11:01am

that elite 11 class was horrible..

canadiancougar624

11/25/14 11:11am

Not any different at BYU than other places IMO

BYUfan92

11/25/14 2:02pm

Whatchoo talkin' bout Willis? Signed Matt Reynolds

icecougar

11/25/14 8:24pm

it's just the way it is. go back and look at the top 10 or 20 qb's in each

macaroni

11/25/14 11:07am

Same thing could be said about NFL - look at starters there now. Romo was never

BYUfan92

11/25/14 2:10pm

Not sure about Munns, but Lark:

SonsOfAlvin

11/25/14 11:20am

I wonder if its because Doman was more interested in a mobile qb style offense

bald man

11/25/14 11:24am

Riley played much better than Lark in practice...that is why

Thrill

11/25/14 11:30am

Lark didn't have the GRIT!!!

nhatch82

11/25/14 11:37am

A healthy riley wasn't a bad qb. A better oline and we win more games.

bald man

11/25/14 11:51am

IMO, part of being an effective coach is being able to handle/manage those egos

11/25/14 2:50pm

We saw what Lark had to offer against SDSU. No TD drives...

BarraCouga

11/25/14 3:11pm

RE: We saw what Lark had to offer against SDSU. No TD drives...

SonsOfAlvin

11/25/14 4:28pm

who's to say Riley would've done any better?

icecougar

11/25/14 8:22pm

I'm glad McMahon wasn't arrogant or he wouldn't have been in the HOF.

CoogsWin

11/25/14 3:33pm

Second from the left is a develope.

Boxey

11/25/14 2:27pm

it started with bad timing on their part...

icecougar

11/25/14 8:06pm

4 is asking a bit much, if you have two solid QBs on the roster you're in good

PoopTown LLC

11/25/14 2:58pm

now there's a CB conclusion

southernfriedcougar

11/25/14 10:45am

?

newey-west

11/25/14 10:48am

how about "assumption."

southernfriedcougar

11/25/14 10:50am

How about question?

newey-west

11/25/14 10:51am

how about admitting you know exactly what I'm talking about.

southernfriedcougar

11/25/14 10:54am

Are you just stringing random words together?

newey-west

11/25/14 11:01am

Maybe Heaps has another year

RC Vikings

11/25/14 10:50am

I think BYU is trying out a radical approach to QB recruiting:

Ham

11/25/14 10:53am

Listening to Monty this morning....He talked to Hosick last night....

Bonoman

11/25/14 10:54am

Then move Hill to the slot and put Hosick at QB.

scott715

11/25/14 10:58am

lol, okay then he's not still committed. Actions speak louder than words.

Grit for Brains

11/25/14 12:54pm

FYI....Hosick is on with Gunther this evening at 6:00 on 1320

Bonoman

11/25/14 10:56am

trying to get him to utah now

jwf

11/25/14 10:58am

He tweeted just last night about arriving to BYU. Cracked a joke about

ocmyhome

11/25/14 2:23pm

I have no idea why so many people are acting like he's

southernfriedcougar

11/25/14 2:28pm

Yea, I mean, it may be true that he's looking elsewhere, but it's not evident

ocmyhome

11/25/14 2:31pm

This shouldn't be happening at BYU. No backup QBs in the stable.

Real Men Wear Blue

11/25/14 3:44pm

I'm of the opinion that BYU needs Juniors/Seniors always starting at QB.

newey-west

11/25/14 4:05pm

No way that happens.

southernfriedcougar

11/25/14 4:07pm

Why do you think this?

newey-west

11/25/14 4:11pm

Who said anything about transferring?

southernfriedcougar

11/25/14 4:22pm

I was just wondering how you thought that it would work out.

newey-west

11/25/14 4:52pm

Sure but it works out that way because that's just how things

southernfriedcougar

11/25/14 5:04pm

Winston has an advantage in that he is surrounded by NFL prospects.

newey-west

11/25/14 5:23pm

RE: Winston has an advantage in that he is surrounded by NFL prospects.

southernfriedcougar

11/25/14 6:26pm

I think that there's plenty of evidence to suggest a causal relation between

newey-west

11/25/14 7:01pm

you didn't answer my question.

southernfriedcougar

11/25/14 7:05pm

Sorry--I didn't realize that it was an actual question. I thought you were just

newey-west

11/25/14 7:10pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad