LOL Your "scientific" poll is just 2 hrs old..

Report problem with this ad

Oct 25, 2016
11:05:13am

DumpsterFire Contributor

Report problem with this ad

DumpsterFire

New username: NSFW
Bio page: DumpsterFire
Joined: Oct 19, 2014
Last login: Sep 10, 2017
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

To Taysomites: Explain why TM doesn't deserve the chance to show what he's got..

Shteve

10/25/16 2:26am

Just to correct the record, 7 drops, 9 drops, and 6 drops in the games that I've

Cougarrrs

10/25/16 3:12am

Drop rates like that point to something other than poor WRs primarily.

mantis mutu

10/25/16 4:15am

For the record ...

ManicBlue

10/25/16 5:03am

That's true of ALL QB ratings.

mantis mutu

10/25/16 5:16am

Also, we have to factor yards per completion to determine just how poor that

mantis mutu

10/25/16 5:26am

RE: Also, we have to factor yards per completion to determine just how poor that

ManicBlue

10/25/16 9:58am

Analysts...apologists...

mantis mutu

10/25/16 10:20am

Call me an apologist if you want but I'm just trying to give

ManicBlue

10/25/16 10:26am

I'm just saying many of the media analysts for BYU are being Taysom apologists

mantis mutu

10/25/16 10:31am

RE: I'm just saying many of the media analysts for BYU are being Taysom

ManicBlue

10/25/16 11:00am

Coaches have stated otherwise

Mises

10/25/16 11:57am

Taysom also does not have the ability to throw receivers open.

Shteve

10/25/16 11:59am

hahahaha ... you can't 'throw receivers open' when those receivers can't

ManicBlue

10/25/16 1:08pm

Watch the NFL

SC-Zoobie

10/25/16 4:26pm

You must not understand what throwing a receiver open is.

BigTD

10/26/16 4:41pm

Taysom is the 111th rated FBS quarterback. It's not because of dropped passes.

OpusX

10/25/16 9:35am

RE: Taysom is the 111th rated FBS quarterback. It's not because of dropped

ManicBlue

10/25/16 10:02am

That's a pretty bad stat even with our schedule and the people around the QB

deljdc

10/25/16 12:09pm

I have seen this general statement a few times, and it bothers me

10/25/16 9:51am

WR drops aren't solely on the WR.

Bryceo19

10/25/16 6:13am

If it hits them in the hands, then yes, it is solely on the receivers.

Freddie Cougar

10/25/16 7:13am

Says someone who has never played WR... that is cliche and ignorant.

TheLoneCougar

10/25/16 8:05am

LOL. That's exactly what I played. Any WR would say the exact same thing.

Freddie Cougar

10/25/16 8:15am

Right...keep using that cliche term. Not accurate at all.

TheLoneCougar

10/25/16 8:22am

What cliche term? Last game several very catchable balls were dropped

Freddie Cougar

10/25/16 8:26am

Yes, but not every ball has been "catchable" this year.

TheLoneCougar

10/25/16 8:39am

Good thing I never said that then. What I said is if it hits them in the hands

Freddie Cougar

10/25/16 9:53am

LOL... Your right I bet most WR would argue that it's not their job to catch a ball...

byu_coug

10/25/16 8:26am

Did I say that anywhere, seriously? Please pull up a quote.

TheLoneCougar

10/25/16 8:40am

LOL...

byu_coug

10/25/16 9:08am

Having played WR in HS, I never blamed QB for any of my drops

Y4LYFE

10/25/16 8:35am

And that is probably the mentality that you should have had at the time.

TheLoneCougar

10/25/16 8:46am

There is a difference in an amazing effort to touch a ball...

byu_coug

10/25/16 9:29am

Is every ball that hits a receivers hands equally catchable?

j20

10/25/16 10:34am

Backups are also there to provide

truecougster

10/25/16 7:28am

I would love to see this broken down. I don't believe the numbers. Are we

Ash

10/25/16 9:11am

Yet u happily count Moroni Top 10 acrobatic TD catch as a completion...SMH

DumpsterFire

10/25/16 9:17am

Huh? That was a great throw.

Mises

10/25/16 12:04pm

I don't think anyone is saying TM "doesn't deserve a chance"

byu_coug

10/25/16 3:13am

When he says "I don't think" you understand the value of his opinion and post

travelcoug

10/25/16 3:25am

To Anti-Taysom Detmerites...

dfudge

10/25/16 3:29am

^^^This^^^

Cougarrrs

10/25/16 3:32am

We tried a fake punt on 4th and 19 from the 5. It's fair to doubt the judgment..

OpusX

10/25/16 4:29am

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

10/25/16 6:20am

^^^this^^^

MangyUte

10/25/16 6:36am

Feels Taysom is held back from his strengths. Tanner benched, Talent squatted!

stealth

10/25/16 2:04pm

To the Anti-Anti Taysom Detmerites...

Beeg

10/25/16 6:29am

Oh, I am not worried about the coaches at all.

dfudge

10/25/16 8:52am

Oh! That all of CB could be as wise as dfudge!

baastablue

10/25/16 9:48am

STANDARD = record against current P5. BM was (23-31) @ 42.5%, KS is 50%

farsurfer

10/25/16 11:05am

A coaches popularity goes down 10% every year he is in charge. Liking a coach

Beeg

10/25/16 12:19pm

As far as my standard (record vs. P5 schools) KS beats BM 50% > 42.5% !!!!!!

farsurfer

10/26/16 3:33am

Your expectations must have been too high this season. He's done alright.

j20

10/26/16 8:20am

I'm just saying he is doing better than Bronco did -plus he is likable w/+energy

farsurfer

10/26/16 12:39pm

He has "done alright" but isn't "doing alright" what pushed BM out?

Beeg

10/28/16 10:57am

This thread is dead dude

Machiavelli

10/28/16 11:03am

...and yet here we are.

Beeg

10/28/16 11:14am

Because that is not how running a football team works.

Six Foot Seven

10/25/16 4:28am

Competition doesn't work? Meritocracy is invalid?

Beeg

10/25/16 6:32am

No, they do. And your claims for otherwise are unfounded.

Six Foot Seven

10/25/16 6:35am

Speaking of childish and stupid...

Beeg

10/25/16 6:40am

Riley Nelson was a COMPLETELY different situation, chump.

Six Foot Seven

10/25/16 6:45am

The margins are slightly different, but the argument is exactly the same.

Beeg

10/25/16 7:15am

The bad play didn't begin with the broken back. There were issues and criticism

TheLoneCougar

10/25/16 8:08am

How do you know there hasn't been a re-evaluation process??

byu_coug

10/25/16 7:58am

Perhaps they have evaluated. If so, at 4 losses maybe we ought to be talking

Beeg

10/25/16 8:43am

FIRE THE COACHES!!!

byu_coug

10/25/16 9:16am

Speaking of baby and the bathwater... I'm not arguing for firing the coaches,

Beeg

10/25/16 12:29pm

3 losses to top 16 teams? you think we are better than that?

10/25/16 10:07am

RE: How do you know there hasn't been a re-evaluation process??

hamaca

10/25/16 8:44am

Does that argument include your stated opinion, or just mine bc it's different?

Beeg

10/25/16 11:30am

WRs drop 5-15 per game

Y4LYFE

10/25/16 6:18am

5-15?! Wow, never seen 15 dropped balls in a game...

TheLoneCougar

10/25/16 8:09am

Whoever is to blame, coaches know best and hold no blame An opinion otherwise..

marklar39

10/25/16 6:26am

you earn playing time in practice. it's that simple. despite your claim otherwise, Tanner does have a chance to show

HarlemCoug

10/25/16 6:49am

Tanner will get and should get some playing time in the coming weeks

CougarsFanSince80s

10/25/16 8:45am

Sorry, this post was in reply to the OP

CougarsFanSince80s

10/25/16 8:49am

And listening to the Royal Blue podcast, they say he isn't better at practice.

quikryptonite

10/25/16 8:52am

Deserve? LOL. What does that have to do with anything?

Freddie Cougar

10/25/16 6:58am

It all comes down to having confidence in the coaches.

PJMort

10/25/16 7:05am

I'm not a Taysomite but doesn't TM get that chance in practice? preseason?

(Private)

10/25/16 7:46am

He will.....against SUU and UMASS. Maybe even Utah St.

CObluezone

10/25/16 7:59am

I think Tanner deserves no shot...

Eddie

10/25/16 9:08am

So once we all decide TM should get a chance, then what? What's the point?

Machiavelli

10/25/16 9:15am

That's what I was thinking.

dfudge

10/25/16 9:31am

Because Taysom is doing well. That was easy.

Mark

10/25/16 9:15am

which game was out of reach where that opportunity was obvious?

10/25/16 9:26am

He's going to be playing against the crap teams moving forward...

Circaman12

10/25/16 9:36am

RE: To Taysomites: Explain why TM doesn't deserve the chance to show what he's

Cookiecoug

10/25/16 9:40am

What if he doesn't? We're assuming TH will blow these team out of the water.

Ash

10/25/16 9:42am

I don't think Taysom supporters are trying to bar Tanner from starting

Litigation Jackson

10/25/16 9:47am

Can't explain it. Next.

hamaca

10/25/16 10:31am

FYI, only ~20% of CBers really want Tanner to start. Vast majority is happy

Machiavelli

10/25/16 10:50am

LOL Your "scientific" poll is just 2 hrs old..

DumpsterFire

10/25/16 11:05am

Hold on, where did I say "scientific"???????????????????????????????

Machiavelli

10/25/16 12:07pm

LOL 25% now want Tanner, and Rising...LOL

DumpsterFire

10/25/16 11:07am

Yep, that's how polls work my friend.

Machiavelli

10/25/16 12:08pm

Beyond the fact that a seasoned competent veteran coach doesn't think so?

yewtsrnogood

10/25/16 12:40pm

This is correct.

Posting on CougarBoard