If it costs you money, he should reimburse you. Otherwise, I'm not sure why

Sep 4, 2019
3:51:28pm

SoCalCoug All-American

he needs punishment. There are natural consequences of not practicing piano.

You don't want to push him and make him resent it, do you?

Report problem with this ad

SoCalCoug

Bio page: SoCalCoug
Joined: May 3, 2001
Last login: Apr 28, 2024
Total posts: 52,838 (5,325 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

14 yr old refuses to go to piano lesson. What should the punishment be?

Iman23

9/4/19 3:40pm

Stop piano lessons

Wingnut

9/4/19 3:41pm

^^THis

IceBlueCoug

9/4/19 3:45pm

Possibly have the lesson fee deducted from his allowance?

BP4byu

9/4/19 3:41pm

Wow. That's taking it to the next level

TNT

9/4/19 3:42pm

I would never go again after that

Grit for Brains

9/4/19 3:43pm

Take him to Elton John tonight and show him what he could be if he practices a

RC Vikings

9/4/19 3:43pm

Wouldn't that be deception? Oh wait. You could have been saying BYU athletics*

TNT

9/4/19 3:45pm

I thought the piano lesson was the punishment...

foofcoug

9/4/19 3:43pm

Have a frank discussion about the value he places on it. If you really want to die on that hill, charge him for lesson.

Soupie

9/4/19 3:43pm

Ya... why are you making a 14 yr old take piano lessons? Would you

kotacoug

9/4/19 3:44pm

This is the question.

Alister Mackenzie

9/4/19 3:45pm

Depends. Maybe Iman23 is related to LaVar Ball

TNT

9/4/19 3:46pm

If I had already paid for the season, I would make him go and play.

BrutusBuckeye

9/4/19 3:47pm

What if you made him sign up to play basketball which I’m going to make a huge

kotacoug

9/4/19 4:27pm

No, I didn't make him sign up for basketball. However, he got discouraged

BrutusBuckeye

9/4/19 4:36pm

Because he usually likes it. And usually doesn't fight it, but mostly because

Iman23

9/4/19 3:49pm

There's no difference. If it's on par with chores or church attendance, then

Memmo

9/4/19 3:53pm

I don't see a difference.

Mitty

9/4/19 11:08pm

he never said he was making him take lessons. Give him a break. Maybe the kid

buckeyecougarguy

9/4/19 3:50pm

If I allowed my kids to quit every time they say they don't want to go to practice...

cougfanblue

9/4/19 4:00pm

Let him play sports

YIsForBrigham

9/4/19 3:44pm

Is he not wanting to go to avoid having to face his teacher after not practicing?

cougfanblue

9/4/19 3:46pm

I think your first question is the answer...

Iman23

9/4/19 3:47pm

I was him way too many times. It's why I'm not very good.

cougfanblue

9/4/19 3:55pm

about the time he's 16 and girls gather round him at the piano, then he'll be

StarMan

9/4/19 4:04pm

This could be. TNT never practiced as a teenager

TNT

9/4/19 3:47pm

My wife gave out so many (like) "Get Out of Jail Free" cards to her piano

StarMan

9/4/19 3:54pm

Probably a good strategy.

cougfanblue

9/4/19 3:56pm

That's actually a good idea

TNT

9/4/19 3:57pm

Because it was hers and not mine? I think I agree with you. 🙂

StarMan

9/4/19 3:57pm

Oh. Uh. Sorry. No he meant that would be much more productive

TNT

9/4/19 3:59pm

If it costs you money, he should reimburse you. Otherwise, I'm not sure why

SoCalCoug

9/4/19 3:51pm

Sounds like he hasn't practiced enough and is concerned the teacher

CLCougar

9/4/19 3:52pm

Tickets to a UoU drama department production

Borg

9/4/19 3:54pm

Is his teacher hot? Probably get better participation if shes hot

WDaddy

9/4/19 3:54pm

Jefe gets upset when I use the H word

Croweater

9/4/19 4:42pm

Apparently Jefe doesn't care to moderate anymore

WDaddy

9/4/19 4:49pm

Make them attend a Yanni concert. They'll see how cool they can be if they practice

bus driverman

9/4/19 3:57pm

Find a teacher who lets him play songs he wants to play.

ldssdl

9/4/19 3:59pm

Ha! My 12 year old is currently yelling at me about this, too.

fattycoug

9/4/19 3:59pm

I don't know if this helps, but here's our experience:

jdub

9/4/19 4:01pm

The "IF and ONLY IF" part kinda felt like you were doing some forcing.

SandYFan

9/4/19 4:21pm

Well, maybe a little, but we gave them a choice between options. And they readily agreed.

jdub

9/4/19 7:07pm

when I was 12 and stopped taking lessons, one of biggest regrets of my life

redlemmons

9/4/19 4:05pm

Everybody says this (including me) but here's the thing....

fulano

9/4/19 4:57pm

Time to ask him if he really wants to play the piano?

lightmann

9/4/19 4:06pm

It might be time to channel your son’s musical talent in another direction.

ataylor

9/4/19 4:53pm

Has he been circumcised?

Belboz

9/4/19 4:53pm

Exile

LaVellIfIKnow

9/4/19 5:22pm

I would tell him that if he can’t adequately express why he doesn’t want to go

StantonMac

9/4/19 5:34pm

Sure you want to fight that battle? Let it go, man. That's about the age I

Mitty

9/4/19 11:06pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad