He played well and when he got injured a giant SFU they were winning. Not sure what you’re talking about here. Not to mention spring and fall camps matter a lot more than single games unless one guy is just atrocious in a game and Hall was certainly not atrocious, in fact he played pretty well, had a lead, out his team in position to win.
If BYU had punted to Boise and they’d scored and won like those last two games none of you would be claiming Romney superiority even thigh Romney would have had nothing to do with the loss it would have been on the defense just like the previous two were mostly on the defense and it’s inability to hold a lead late.