I really value your opinion and more often than not I align with yours, but I don't know how Hall has earned it. Not knocking the kid but he's only earned it because of what he did against our scout D in Fall camp. He made some great plays against USF but they were mostly with his feet and because he didn't run through his progressions and took off.
He may have more weapons with his feet but Romney was no slouch in that department on Saturday. He throws a better ball than Hall too. He managed the O much better than Hall did and he did it against stiffer competition.
I say Romney over Hall, not because Hall sucks but simply because Romney is better. Based on what I've seen of Hall I don't see him catching up to Wilson anytime soon either.