But our transfer list looked amazing pre-Kalani as well. Max Hall, Taysom, Kurtz

Dec 12, 2019
1:05:01pm

SlantRoute All-American

Squally Canada
Uona Kaveinga
Uani Unga
Harvey Langi
Jonah Trinnaman
Devon Blackman
Isaiah Armstrong
Hebron Fangupo
Chris Badger

Etc.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 12, 2019 at 1:05:01pm

Message modified by SlantRoute on Dec 12, 2019 at 1:06:33pm

Message modified by SlantRoute on Dec 12, 2019 at 1:07:06pm

Message modified by SlantRoute on Dec 12, 2019 at 1:08:43pm

Message modified by SlantRoute on Dec 12, 2019 at 1:11:00pm

Report problem with this ad

SlantRoute

Previous username: truecoug1
Bio page: SlantRoute
Joined: Jan 31, 2008
Last login: Feb 21, 2024
Total posts: 18,188 (87 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Kalani and recruiting.

newbie

12/12/19 10:03am

IMO recruiting hasn’t gotten worse under Kalani, but it hasn’t gotten better like we all thought it would

DieHarder

12/12/19 10:05am

RE: IMO recruiting hasn’t gotten worse under Kalani, but it hasn’t

Benfica1

12/12/19 10:17am

RE: IMO recruiting hasn’t gotten worse under Kalani, but it hasn’t

akbarishiwatsu

12/12/19 2:46pm

RE: IMO recruiting hasn’t gotten worse under Kalani, but it hasn’t

Benfica1

12/13/19 8:32am

That’s the best way to sum it up

cougfanz

12/12/19 10:20am

He did well with transfers his first season. I think it will trend up soon.

Benfica1

12/12/19 10:23am

The transfer and post-mission offer list is pretty good

donnerstag

12/12/19 10:32am

That's a pretty good list. 8 starters and 7 from P5 programs

Doogal McCougar

12/12/19 10:36am

The 2 that are redshirting will be helpful to the program in 2020

donnerstag

12/12/19 10:42am

We’ve run through most of those

D.T. Survivor

12/12/19 12:19pm

But our transfer list looked amazing pre-Kalani as well. Max Hall, Taysom, Kurtz

SlantRoute

12/12/19 1:05pm

Max Hall, Taysom Hill, Jan Jorgensen, and Andrew Rich were all transfers and are

Gorum the Old

12/12/19 2:01pm

I think the new coaching staff has been killing it

Srg

12/12/19 12:19pm

This is the right perspective. Look at the depth chart and team talent.

Doogal McCougar

12/12/19 12:36pm

Good recruiting usually depends on a good on-field product.

vagabonder

12/12/19 10:05am

Anyone short of Andy Reid means BYU is pretty stuck where they’re at recruiting

franklyvulgar

12/12/19 10:08am

Correct assessment. Mediocre recruiting + average coaching = Bad losses

MichCoug

12/12/19 10:08am

And really good wins?

Blue Cat

12/12/19 10:13am

= inconsistency

Yunit

12/12/19 12:48pm

Handful - .500 record after multiple years & inexplicably bad losses.

MichCoug

12/12/19 1:19pm

Independence has killed us. If Kalani can't recruit LDS kids to BYU, nobody can.

Backcountry

12/12/19 10:10am

Utter fiction.

All-American

12/12/19 10:14am

Thats a rosy perspetive

Backcountry

12/12/19 10:18am

To be fair

JKLCoug

12/12/19 10:50am

Would be worse in the MWC. It ain't what it was 9 years ago

mcnasty

12/12/19 2:58pm

Talent evaluation and attrition has improved under Kalani

donnerstag

12/12/19 10:13am

Attrition actually seems to have gotten worse under Kalani, but I

kimdaddy35

12/12/19 10:53am

As I look at each position group, the talent of the roster

donnerstag

12/12/19 10:59am

Oh I don't see that at all. So that is a lot of personal bias coming through.

kimdaddy35

12/12/19 11:19am

Let's see here

donnerstag

12/12/19 11:45am

Again, I don't think you are being even close to rational

kimdaddy35

12/12/19 12:15pm

Kalani inherited and amazing QB and RB situation.

Gorum the Old

12/12/19 2:54pm

For one year, the QB and RB situation was excellent

donnerstag

12/12/19 3:03pm

Squally was actually pretty good last year but got hurt quick

puntersarepeople

12/12/19 5:53pm

What Bronco had lined up for 2017 was not what Kalani put on the field.

Gorum the Old

12/16/19 9:20am

(modify: was not what the OC put on the field).

Benfica1

12/16/19 9:24am

Yea.. don't forget Bronco's biggest recruit..

TheLost

12/16/19 9:30am

I'd assign at least 50% of Mangum's success as a freshman to his receivers

donnerstag

12/16/19 10:15am

It's amazing how that staff got 9 regular season wins from those scrubs.

kooogar

12/12/19 2:56pm

The receiving corps in 2015 was the best in the last 15 seasons

donnerstag

12/12/19 3:06pm

There is absolutely no evidence for this, but it keeps getting said on CB

runnincoug

12/12/19 12:24pm

I do think 2017 did more damage to confidence in the program. BYU needs to win

Benfica1

12/12/19 10:16am

This, winning is needed to help recruiting

kimdaddy35

12/12/19 10:55am

9-10 wins each season will, “help to build” confidence????

itsuptoyou

12/12/19 6:03pm

We have not lost out on *every* major Latter-day Saint recruit

Doogal McCougar

12/12/19 10:33am

Yes recruiting and rankings has only gone downhill under Sitake

kimdaddy35

12/12/19 10:50am

I think Sitake has better depth players than Bronco did, but Bronco got a couple more high end per class guys.

Turnpike Lane

12/12/19 12:15pm

We don’t seem to have game changers anymore

D.T. Survivor

12/12/19 12:39pm

Anymore? We had one last year in Sione and arguably Corbin

puntersarepeople

12/12/19 2:55pm

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

TheLost

12/12/19 1:37pm

This is the most incorrect post ever posted on this board. Blatantly false.

itsuptoyou

12/12/19 6:12pm

The hard part is staying in

puntersarepeople

12/12/19 7:02pm

Most BYU fans are living in the past.. people in/around the program know

TheLost

12/12/19 8:12pm

Hahaha. Oh dude. I’m dying. 😂 😂 😂 😂

itsuptoyou

12/12/19 9:36pm

Hahahahahahahahahaha. Oh man. You guys....

itsuptoyou

12/12/19 9:35pm

LOL. Please share some actual insight on how you know that it is easy to get in.

Benfica1

12/16/19 9:57am

While I agree it is hard to get in as a regular student, getting into BYU

Yunit

12/16/19 2:13pm

Knowledge or opinion? Please share actual numbers and information.

Benfica1

12/16/19 2:16pm

My nephew got in with a 19 on the ACT and 3.0 gpa

Yunit

12/17/19 10:46am

10 years ago. OK. I have a story about when I was in high school and a kid from

Benfica1

12/17/19 11:18am

I guess the problem I have is that I haven't heard anything concrete about the

Yunit

12/17/19 3:19pm

RE: I guess the problem I have is that I haven't heard anything concrete about

TheLost

12/17/19 3:43pm

I had to read the post after seeing that response. Let down, tbh

All-American

12/12/19 8:00pm

How much of the drop is Kalani as a recruiter and how much because of our record

morningcalmcougar

12/12/19 3:22pm

Incorrect. I assume the "every major LDS" thing is hyperbole?

Lip Gallagher

12/12/19 4:48pm

Shame on us for assuming he could out-recruit a P5 program 40 miles away

Posting on CougarBoard