Hindsight is 20-20. He even said he didn’t want BYU. Not sure that reflects badly on anyone. IIRC he wasn’t an option

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 29, 2020
6:04:47pm

Hank Rearden Truly Addicted User

Hindsight is 20-20. He even said he didn’t want BYU. Not sure that reflects badly on anyone. IIRC he wasn’t an option

for anyone until Utah sold out on Indiana’s backup QB. 🙂

I agree that as things have played out, we were lucky to get him. But I don’t want BYU going too hard after 3 star kids who don’t want to come to BYU. Thats a bad recruiting strategy IMO.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Oct 29, 2020 at 6:04:47pm

Message modified by Hank Rearden on Oct 29, 2020 at 6:34:17pm

Report problem with this ad

Hank Rearden

Previous username: Twinblue
Bio page: Hank Rearden
Joined: Jun 9, 2003
Last login: May 21, 2024
Total posts: 34,576 (4,555 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

ZW's candor is both refreshing and a little terrifying.

Ham

10/29/20 5:38pm

I think it wasn’t fair to Ty to give him a coordinator spot.

10/29/20 5:49pm

Agreed. Ty was in over his head as OC.

Forzaitalia

10/29/20 6:01pm

I'll say it again. I love BYU players but not a single starter on O in 2017

rcbyufan

10/29/20 6:48pm

While true I think there is little reason to expect Ty would’ve been able to

puntersarepeople

10/30/20 12:01am

I'd have to look back but aren't half of these starters from back when Ty was

rcbyufan

10/30/20 8:30am

He didn’t impress at the WR and QB positions

puntersarepeople

10/30/20 8:33am

I agree with this, but he said in several interviews he wasn't coming unless it

Lance71

10/29/20 6:32pm

He also required most of the assistant coaches’ pool of funds. That’s why the

BYUHgrad

10/29/20 7:56pm

I don’t know if it was as much his ego as he enjoyed what he was doing

cougarfann888

10/30/20 12:18am

I’m not sure he would make a great quarterback coach

10/29/20 7:55pm

Totally, 100% disagree. It takes only 2 things to be a great coach/teacher:

BleedCougarBlue2

10/29/20 8:14pm

The QB's under Ty were awful at going through their reads. Ty was such a natural

Lance71

10/29/20 8:23pm

Disagree. And as further evidence of his teaching skills, it is well known that

BleedCougarBlue2

10/29/20 8:34pm

Again, that’s not the same as getting a college QB to succeed. Lots of NFL

10/29/20 8:39pm

I know this hurts for people to hear but Ty was not a good OC and his QBs didn’t

Coug Man in Florida

10/29/20 11:03pm

I'd like to see you say that to his face without knowing the backstory...

LEDSFW

10/29/20 6:03pm

There's another side to that view. 1. KS went out and recruited ZW hard despite

Forzaitalia

10/29/20 6:46pm

Yeah it is true that Kalani went hard after Wilson. But then it's also ....

LEDSFW

10/29/20 10:56pm

Lots of emotional arguments in there and stuff I can only speculate about. No-

Forzaitalia

10/30/20 12:25am

I have two words for you, Zadock Dinklemann.

CougarTailDevourer

10/29/20 7:17pm

Two other words...

LEDSFW

10/29/20 10:57pm

Sure does. Dinklemann is the reason why Ty didn't have a schollie to offer

CougarTailDevourer

10/29/20 11:27pm

Ty was an amazing QB, and has a great mind for football, but...

Ham

10/29/20 8:37pm

So you were there. It was Ty's choice. You are unwilling to accept the....

LEDSFW

10/29/20 11:05pm

You're probably right.

Ham

10/30/20 10:02am

RE: I'd like to see you say that to his face without knowing the backstory...

Shawn paul

10/29/20 9:12pm

I look forward to Ty proving you right if he can find someone to hire him

MyTwoCents

10/29/20 9:25pm

Ty had two NFLers in his backfield his first year and somehow that offense was

Ozymandias

10/30/20 7:34am

I was neighbors with a qb recruit during this- BYU was actively recruiting 2

1984coug

10/30/20 8:41am

Hindsight is 20-20. He even said he didn’t want BYU. Not sure that reflects badly on anyone. IIRC he wasn’t an option

10/29/20 6:04pm

It's great that we got Zach, but I'd wager that part of what motivates him to be

BYUFootballisBack

10/29/20 6:21pm

Coming to BYU also opened his eyes to the true ugliness at Utah. Zach's brother

Lance71

10/29/20 6:36pm

I don’t think “they don’t want any part of Utah” is true.

SlantRoute

10/29/20 8:12pm

It’s absolutely true. The way the parents have been treated, they’re stone.

cougfan03

10/29/20 11:01pm

BYU fans didn't treat then very well last year either. Especially his mom.

Schultz is back

10/30/20 7:11am

No doubt that is a big part of his motivation. What high-caliber athlete would

BleedCougarBlue2

10/29/20 8:20pm

Bashing Detmer is poor form.

ParentingNotForSissy

10/29/20 9:50pm

I think defending him is just as poor.

TheWoodman

10/29/20 10:20pm

Yes. Failing to face reality helps nothing. Time focus on Ty the great player.

Forzaitalia

10/29/20 10:27pm

Why would you bash detmer and in the same message say why are we talking

ChiTownCougarV2

10/30/20 12:00am

It should be an automatic lifetime ban

ChiTownCougarV2

10/29/20 11:57pm

BYU never should have hired him. It was a terrible, short-sighted decision.

Ham

10/30/20 10:04am

What happened happened but no slander shall be directed towards Ty. He’s my

ChiTownCougarV2

10/29/20 11:55pm

I don't have the luxury of recalling memories of Ty as a player.

Ham

10/30/20 10:11am

Agreed but he’s BYU’s only Heisman winner and a hero whether you remember him

ChiTownCougarV2

10/30/20 11:39am

I keep getting a vibe from Zach that he is not a BYU guy. I realize that he was

CT98

10/30/20 11:57am

Last I checked, yes. Although I did see an awful photoshop job of him in red.

10/30/20 12:00pm

Come on...you know what I mean. Surely there are other CBers who get this vibe

CT98

10/30/20 12:10pm

When we had family at the U playing football and other sports we cheered for uta

1984coug

10/30/20 3:07pm

Thank you for your comment. This is what I think will happen with the Wilsons

CT98

10/30/20 3:15pm

I hope not

puntersarepeople

10/30/20 3:25pm

RE: Thank you for your comment. This is what I think will happen with the

Shawn paul

10/30/20 6:43pm

His little brother, who was a bigger recruit than him, committed to BYU. And he

Lance71

10/30/20 12:23pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad