Also, BYU did not play ANY P5 schools in 2020. Our SOS in 2020 was 106 which is not even close to normal or

Nov 22, 2022
9:38:59am

ManicBlue Truly Addicted User

close to what it will be next year. Tuiaki's scheme and our talent level can succeed against lower level teams just not well enough against P5 level teams.

Report problem with this ad

ManicBlue

Bio page: ManicBlue
Joined: Jan 10, 2005
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 48,317 (909 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Depth, the problem for BYU…

ChinaFan All-American

11/22/22 12:06am

And yet fans think all that is needed is a couple of new coaches, good

BYURider

11/22/22 12:16am

So you're content to be a mediocre program from now on? smh

ManicBlue

11/22/22 12:25am

Yeah, that’s what he said.

Abe Froman

11/22/22 7:20am

no, but that's what it is. BYU's been a 8-5 / 9-4 program for 50 years with an

BYURider

11/22/22 9:54am

No one is saying we should be seeing 10-2 records every year. Problem is without changes we're likely

ManicBlue

11/22/22 10:06am

OK, I agree with that. We need IMO 4-5 coaches replaced. I really don't want to

BYURider

11/22/22 10:18am

No, problem is that you believe your suggested changes will do more than is possible now with guys who really are doing

ChinaFan

11/22/22 5:28pm

RE: No, problem is that you believe your suggested changes will do more than is possible now with guys who really are

ManicBlue

11/22/22 6:21pm

As a fan, you have few options but being content...

JstSain

11/22/22 12:00pm

Sure I do. Stop buying my season tickets and donating to the CC. Just like people did when Reid was the BB coach.

ManicBlue

11/22/22 2:12pm

You are correct...that is an option, but im not sure that go you want you wanted

JstSain

11/22/22 3:59pm

RE: You are correct...that is an option, but im not sure that go you want you wanted

ManicBlue

11/22/22 4:14pm

After 44 years? What has changed?

JstSain

11/22/22 5:12pm

RE: After 44 years? What has changed?

ManicBlue

11/22/22 6:15pm

Coaches are responsible for depth.

panacablue

11/22/22 12:33am

can't squeeze water from a rock my friend, I already laid out the limitations,

ChinaFan

11/22/22 5:29pm

How about just not a bottom ten defense? Apparently too much to ask

BYU '80

11/22/22 2:18am

There are 6 teams in the top 25 with 50th or worse defenses.

ManicBlue

11/22/22 2:40am

And byu could be there right with them but UCLA’s d looks pretty good at 81

BYU '80

11/22/22 3:35am

BYU having an elite offense last year is what masked how bad our defense was. As you said,

ManicBlue

11/22/22 9:41am

A couple of things ...

ManicBlue

11/22/22 12:24am

I think those top notch S & C staffs at places like Alabama are getting the help of top shelf pharmaceuticals.

PJMort

11/22/22 8:04am

I don’t think #4 is accurate. Alabama keeps a lot of player on the bench

ThatBYUFan

11/22/22 10:46am

Sure but they have players transfer too and not every team is Alabama that is competing for a NC every year.

ManicBlue

11/22/22 11:00am

I don't think there are too many fans who have expectations of BYU competing

wjman11

11/22/22 12:47am

Look here everyone, an informed take, complete with actual data and citations.

legiaourbana

11/22/22 4:33am

Are those allowed?

crazY

11/22/22 8:07am

Removing 2020 is inappropriate in this analysis. Defensive efficiency adjusts

NYC and Japan

11/22/22 7:44am

The reason for removing 2020 wouldn’t be because it doesn’t fit the narrative

wjman11

11/22/22 8:13am

Also, BYU did not play ANY P5 schools in 2020. Our SOS in 2020 was 106 which is not even close to normal or

ManicBlue

11/22/22 9:38am

Hard to argue too much with this analysis.

Socrates Johnson

11/22/22 7:17am

Depth is a problem at every school outside the Bamas, OSU and Georgias

orrin7

11/22/22 7:22am

During #3 Michigan's Saturday game, the commentators kept talking about how

Still Questing

11/22/22 7:57am

Now do all the other B12 schools.

Turnpike Lane

11/22/22 7:26am

There are clear scheme and strategy decisions that are lacking

canuckchuck

11/22/22 7:36am

The issue(s) is / are scheme and depth. Both are big issues.

NYC and Japan

11/22/22 7:47am

Yup, but it's always been this way, even in successful eras

akbarishiwatsu

11/22/22 10:01am

This is the reality few here want to face. Great post

JstSain

11/22/22 4:00pm

Those are challenges and a good coach will not use that as an excuse....

Posting on CougarBoard