My Account
Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Mar 20, 2017
6:50
:41
pm
g$
All-American
yeah, except that whole part about statistical analysis validating star ratings
In basically every in depth review of it that I have seen for the last 20 or so years.... except for that, sure.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
g$
Bio page
g$
Joined
Jul 23, 2001
Last login
May 1, 2024
Total posts
10,000 (2,662 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
The more I think about it, the more I realize that the Star ratings will never mean as much to BYU as it will to teams..
Adrielle
Semi-Legendary
3/20/17 6:43pm
Not to mention how much missions can change things.
ballen
3/20/17 6:46pm
Mission trip = one star ⭐️ upgrade
Mathlete
3/20/17 7:08pm
It's kind of corny how much stalk people put into this arbitrary system.
Thunder Buddy
3/20/17 6:47pm
i think a lot of 4 and 5* guys are rated there because they matured early and
johnnycarson
3/20/17 6:47pm
yeah, except that whole part about statistical analysis validating star ratings
g$
3/20/17 6:50pm
You might have missed my main point...
Adrielle
3/20/17 7:01pm
It's not that crazy that so few Super Bowl starters were 4 or 5 star guys
Martin Van Nostrand
3/20/17 7:13pm
I also think superbowl starters is sorta a meaningless stat. much better
johnnycarson
3/20/17 7:19pm
If you had the top LDS recruits, you would have about the #15 best recruiting
g$
3/20/17 7:33pm
Star rating system isn't perfect, but it is directionally correct
Dr T-bone
3/20/17 7:55pm
Sitake made a great point in an interview a couple of months ago.
SoCalCoug
3/20/17 6:53pm
They've never meant much to me
Sea Chicken
3/20/17 7:00pm
Stars don't fully describe a "talent gap." Sitake needs to, and will, continue
southernfriedcougar
3/20/17 7:03pm
The delta is talent development
wilsdad
3/21/17 7:18am
The reason I was thinking about this today was in reference to Chaz
Adrielle
3/20/17 7:09pm
Most any director of any of the services will tell you it does not
southernfriedcougar
3/22/17 5:03pm
More stars = more elite programs recruiting them. So you want players that none
ALUF 1990
3/20/17 7:21pm
Well, Utah has had the success they've had because of it.
southernfriedcougar
3/20/17 7:33pm
It's amazing how bad some people's reading comprehension is.
Adrielle
3/20/17 7:57pm
Okay. How about this idea - go after the kids with elite speed that
ALUF 1990
3/20/17 8:39pm
It's worked for TCU and the U
wilsdad
3/21/17 7:20am
My theory on that is the bad teams have the early picks, and therefore have a
BYUHgrad
3/20/17 8:53pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad