My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jun 22, 2018
10:08
:01
pm
LV Mike
All-American
Because he did some terrible things last year that are unforgettable.
He said things no other sane D1 coaches serious about building a program say.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
LV Mike
Bio page
LV Mike
Joined
Sep 28, 2007
Last login
Jun 14, 2024
Total posts
39,480 (9,542 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
(Link) Kalani gave some insight as to why Tanner struggled so much last season
LifelongAP
6/22/18 7:12pm
The reason why QBs went live in spring is because of what happened with Mangum in fall camp
Indy Coug
6/22/18 7:14pm
It came crashing in beginning with Portland State
YIsForBrigham
6/23/18 1:13am
This is the correct answer. They will force Mangum
Bostonblue
6/23/18 6:35am
Seems then none of our qbs "were remotely the same QB when they were under fire"
viper
6/23/18 8:44am
Its also flat out a rewrite of actual history. Hoge battled
CarolinaCoug
6/23/18 10:58pm
Sounds more like an unprovable excuse
StantonMac
6/22/18 7:15pm
<< Deleted >>
Run-DMT
6/22/18 7:48pm
Kalani has been such a disappointment for me. I was excited and supported the
Gerald-DeGroot
6/23/18 12:28am
Exactly. Kalani was less than fully supportive of Tanner before Portland St
Coogar2
6/23/18 3:27pm
Combine mental laziness with an overly complex Detmer offense = disaster
mudpupper
6/22/18 7:18pm
Looking back I don't think Detmer even knew what his offense was.
kotacoug
6/22/18 7:20pm
Translated: Kalani didn't push his players and hold them accountable.
LV Mike
6/22/18 7:26pm
He publicly places blame with the best of them!
Fervent Cougar
6/22/18 7:28pm
and accepted and acknowledged it was a mistake - his.
basman
6/22/18 7:52pm
Sure didn’t hear that last year!
Fervent Cougar
6/22/18 7:57pm
So why wasn't he fired? If his mistake cost the O then why did he fire others?
thecthdox
6/22/18 8:10pm
Really? This question is even asked? Being fired isn't the only way to be
SUAVO
6/22/18 8:42pm
That's IT! Fire the coach anytime he makes a mistake. Why didn't we think
deljdc
6/23/18 6:42am
So did you support firing Ty Detmer? KS was quick to blame the O staff and fire
thecthdox
6/23/18 8:45am
I see it the same. Thanks
Coogar2
6/23/18 3:29pm
Apples and oranges. I would not support firing Detmer for one mistake.
deljdc
6/24/18 6:26pm
Just to be clear, KS his one mistake was destroying a culture of accountability
thecthdox
6/24/18 6:32pm
No actually, the initial statement that this whole thread is about is that
deljdc
6/26/18 7:11am
Part of the culture of non-accountability - mere symptom of a much bigger
LV Mike
6/26/18 7:42am
Don’t forget he was krylized
Q-grr
6/22/18 9:12pm
There's truly a group of people on here who will spin anything to fit the grudge
Lip Gallagher
6/22/18 7:49pm
He publicly threw TM under the bus...not hard to spin.
Traveshamockery
6/22/18 8:34pm
He did say that last year. CB just likes to harp on the moments he didn't
SUAVO
6/22/18 8:44pm
Because he did some terrible things last year that are unforgettable.
LV Mike
6/22/18 10:08pm
He absolutely did, but the point of the post is that he took responsibility at
SUAVO
6/23/18 7:20am
Sure, Sitake "took responsibility" after complaining about things like his
LV Mike
6/23/18 8:32am
..and he made steps in the offense to correct that. There’s a lot to prove....
icecougar
6/23/18 2:51pm
Confused. Is this what you meant to say? How is that a
soupie
6/23/18 3:06pm
I think he's saying that a lot of coaches play the blame game
SUAVO
6/23/18 10:57pm
His poor record made him lose fan support way more than his disgraceful
SUAVO
6/23/18 10:54pm
RE: He publicly threw TM under the bus...not hard to spin.
Lip Gallagher
6/22/18 9:43pm
TM has thrown himself under the bus for not being mentally ready to compete...
icecougar
6/23/18 3:00pm
What grudge? Sitake blames publicly. His latest take is simply another
LV Mike
6/22/18 10:06pm
Even after a win, he'd make a snide comment at Ty's expense. Inexcusable.
Division Bell
6/23/18 1:03am
That was most evident after the Hawaii victory . . . saying something like:
LV Mike
6/23/18 8:52am
Someone ,should ask ks. "Hey coach, If you played cover zero D with
CarolinaCoug
6/23/18 11:19pm
We already know you're biased against him.
Lip Gallagher
6/23/18 1:29pm
Agreed. I didn't like the antics either but give the guy room to grow.
GOR
6/23/18 1:31pm
And then there are the never ending apologists who are just fine with Sitake's
LV Mike
6/23/18 1:44pm
What’s wrong with saying guys need to compete for their starting jobs? Bronco...
icecougar
6/23/18 3:10pm
He could have said he has made some changes, learned some things from last
LV Mike
6/23/18 4:52pm
I agree with most of what you said last year about Kalani
GOR
6/23/18 3:22pm
This is absolutely hilarious.
Eddie
6/23/18 1:31pm
It's something Sitake didn't need to say publicly. It's just another shot at TY
LV Mike
6/23/18 1:41pm
You guys are a sensitive bunch.
D.T. Survivor
6/23/18 3:03pm
Yyyyyyeah...don’t see it
icecougar
6/23/18 3:19pm
So - tell us about more conspiracy theories you've got.
Eddie
6/23/18 9:27pm
Blame Tanner now before losing so that you look smart
Coogar2
6/23/18 3:28pm
I don't buy that. Hard to regress like that...
Jericho
6/22/18 7:26pm
Was Taysom lazy as well? Because he looked horrid in Ty's offense as well.
mudpupper
6/22/18 7:28pm
This is true. There was something up with the offense
kotacoug
6/22/18 7:29pm
Yeah, I tend to think Ty’s offense was the main problem.
LifelongAP
6/22/18 7:34pm
There was also some visible progress w/ Tanner just before getting injured.
soupie
6/22/18 7:38pm
I tend to think this statement from Kalani is more evidence of the main problem
jdub
6/22/18 8:03pm
Might be true. I don't know enough about the program.
kotacoug
6/22/18 8:05pm
Makes sense
Coogar2
6/23/18 3:30pm
That's because he is Taysom Freaking Hill
Y05
6/23/18 12:56am
No receivers? No prwcticr in it? No blocking?
CarolinaCoug
6/23/18 11:22pm
I believe Ty’s offense was the biggest factor. Taysom was a mediocre QB that
Duke Silver
6/22/18 7:36pm
Gotta love all the revisionist history here in the echo chamber.
CougarThug
6/22/18 7:46pm
<< Deleted >>
rivercitycoug
6/22/18 7:46pm
I never heard what happened to his arm
D.T. Survivor
6/22/18 8:44pm
Kalani, even if true, please keep that stuff between you and your QB
Run-DMT
6/22/18 7:49pm
RE: Kalani, even if true, please keep that stuff between you and your QB
soupie
6/22/18 7:52pm
I don’t think it’s very disparaging. Better than a made up excuse.
D.T. Survivor
6/22/18 8:46pm
I don’t feel he was being disparaging towards Tanner
LifelongAP
6/22/18 9:24pm
That’s one theory.
jkccoug
6/22/18 7:52pm
So he basically just said his starting QB was unmotivated, lacked work ethic
Run-DMT
6/22/18 8:01pm
And yet Kalani still made him his starter?
2FarGone
6/22/18 8:03pm
I agree
cougarmanguy
6/22/18 8:20pm
Tanner said the same thing about himself after 2016 fall camp...
icecougar
6/23/18 3:31pm
Agreed. Lame excuse by Kalani
Coogar2
6/23/18 5:56pm
SLIGHTof hand..mis direction by ks. And completely
CarolinaCoug
6/23/18 11:10pm
I am no longer in Utah to know these things but according to CB
pappabear246
6/22/18 8:23pm
Yes, they’ve tightened up already but some people still want to complain about..
icecougar
6/23/18 3:33pm
I am excited to see how things have changed.
pappabear246
6/24/18 11:57am
Did Kalani take ownership for that decision? He dictated to Ty that Tanner would
unctoothman
6/22/18 8:42pm
Kalani needs to understand you can't treat QBs like you do other positions
Seasider
6/22/18 10:01pm
This reminds me of the Crowtonera
BYU-Laie
6/22/18 11:14pm
I don't think kalani had a great first season. That team underperformed
thebruce
6/23/18 9:09am
It was a pretty good season for his debut.
eddog
6/23/18 11:35am
It would’ve been different if Taysom were 100% healthy...
icecougar
6/23/18 3:57pm
That would have helped but the offense was garbage
thebruce
6/23/18 4:06pm
I agree. Kalani under performed with the talent he had in both years
Coogar2
6/23/18 5:54pm
Lol. We are such a mess of a program.
Gerald-DeGroot
6/22/18 10:07pm
So if he struggles this fall I'll know why
Y4LYFE
6/23/18 12:13am
Ridiculous. If that were the case he shouldn’t even be considered to start this year.
Refugee
6/23/18 12:58am
Don't buy it. That is not what we heard.
coolblue
6/23/18 10:43am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad