I don't think BYU will drop football, but I think the biggest threat may

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 17, 2018
1:07:14pm

mannheimadler All-American

I don't think BYU will drop football, but I think the biggest threat may

actually be the increasing science that has been confirming the dangers of concussions.

I hope football's popularity doesn't wane because of that, but I think it's actually possible that it does. And I could see the church not wanting to sponsor something that could be viewed as endangering students.

Report problem with this ad

mannheimadler

Previous username: TomZarek
Bio page: mannheimadler
Joined: Aug 27, 2009
Last login: May 3, 2024
Total posts: 14,582 (348 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Had a FB conversation with a friend today... he suggested that BYU FB will be

1/17/18 12:33pm

your friend is dumb.

smokymountainrain

1/17/18 12:34pm

You say dumb, but there is a lot of probable turth in that statement.

blackshirts

1/17/18 4:49pm

Yep. If that happens, and the demand for the product drops, the TV contracts

1/17/18 5:30pm

There will be plenty of $$$$ for the Superleague.

blackshirts

1/17/18 5:35pm

Yep. But just like the Bowl Alliance, BCS, P6 and P5, they don't like to share.

1/17/18 5:41pm

Wow, revelation comes to Cougarboard. Whom is the Prophet on this?

stevebyu8

1/18/18 9:05am

Is your friend named Vai?

acougfan

1/17/18 12:34pm

Nope. He refs HS sports.

1/17/18 12:35pm

ah. bonified seers, those high school refs are.

indojoe

1/17/18 12:41pm

I think it's more likely that things play out as your friend suggested

jbcoug

1/17/18 12:36pm

yep. his real gaffe is predicting the 5 year time frame.

smokymountainrain

1/17/18 12:40pm

That's kind of the direction I think it's going as well. I think the push for a

1/17/18 12:41pm

If fan interest & revenue decline to the point where the athletic dept is not

ptcougr

1/17/18 1:30pm

#1 doesn't make sense

Martin Van Nostrand

1/17/18 12:39pm

I may agree if the next round of TV deals don't pick up BYU Football

BruceBruce

1/17/18 12:41pm

Good point. I'm interested to find out how BYU's brand is perceived as an ROI

1/17/18 12:49pm

Five years, no way. Twenty years, its quite possible.

Josef K

1/17/18 12:43pm

1 and 2 are silly. 3 and 4 are legit problems. Our FB teams have picked the wrong times to suck.

byuTX

1/17/18 12:44pm

what recruits?

1/17/18 12:50pm

What is the worth of one soul? how many non mormons come to play and then get

bald man

1/17/18 12:54pm

You'd get a better return by dumping that money into some country in Africa

RC Vikings

1/17/18 2:21pm

Dumping what money? Cougar Club is not going to dump money into Africa!

GilbertAZCougar

1/17/18 2:58pm

Maybe their priorities are wrong.

RC Vikings

1/17/18 3:10pm

Maybe they already pay tithing, fast offerings and humanitarian aid.

GilbertAZCougar

1/17/18 4:30pm

I may quit the church if this happens.

Blue streak

1/17/18 1:00pm

^^^^This^^^^^

jrj84105

1/17/18 4:26pm

I would consider paying my tithes directly to BYU athletics instead of my ward.

Blue streak

1/17/18 4:32pm

I am with you on this. BYU athletics keeps me connected in some ways to the

Manutd

1/17/18 5:22pm

Same for me, athletics is a big tie for me

BYUfan92

1/17/18 5:57pm

May be the most honest post in the history of CB. My vote for POTD

SneakerPimp

1/17/18 6:37pm

Very true. And well said. This is true for way more people than

Jay Rick

1/17/18 8:26pm

Thank you for the compassionate response to my post.

Blue streak

1/18/18 8:35am

Would byu drop football before resigning itself to a navy/army/air force like

RdF3

1/17/18 1:02pm

Not sure. Probably depends on several factors, including space utilization.

1/17/18 1:06pm

In the mid-1990s I saw the Miracle Bowl play in Argentina on TV

2FarGone

1/17/18 1:05pm

I don't think BYU will drop football, but I think the biggest threat may

1/17/18 1:07pm

I know a lot of parents who love FB, but who don't want their kids to play.

1/17/18 1:11pm

You friend is either a Ute or Aggie fan, isn't he?

TheHop

1/17/18 1:15pm

He's right, but for the wrong reasons: 1. Gays; 2. Concussions. 10 years.

Iman23

1/17/18 1:24pm

Oh brother

SWP

1/17/18 1:34pm

No evidence that BYU students are more likely to get married in the temple or

Iman23

1/17/18 1:36pm

Seriously. Merrill Bateman's claim, not mine

SWP

1/17/18 1:37pm

I think you misunderstood what he said. There is data on this that proves it

Iman23

1/17/18 3:13pm

Actually, I'm certain I understood what he was saying. Why? Because it really

SWP

1/17/18 6:51pm

Because the direction is to offer a less expensive

FanofBYU

1/18/18 12:01am

RE: Actually, I'm certain I understood what he was saying. Why? Because it

ManicBlue

1/18/18 1:34pm

BYU students more likely than whom? In the northeast, active LDS YM & YW who

ptcougr

1/17/18 1:52pm

Does that number include RMs? 90% sounds really high if RMs are included

ALUF 1990

1/17/18 2:24pm

I don’t know, but I have heard (2nd hand from area authority) that increasingly

BlueTooth

1/17/18 4:47pm

My ward has 71 YSAs. 2 are active, attending the singles ward, 5 are currently

ptcougr

1/17/18 7:22pm

Wow, that’s pretty close to 90%.

BlueTooth

1/18/18 11:40am

I don't know about 90%. But, when I was in a YSA in California they said 80%

califcougar

1/18/18 1:25pm

Does this strike anyone else as odd? If your numbers are correct

jbcoug

1/17/18 2:25pm

Does seem a bit high. But I know there is concern because it is high.

BlueTooth

1/17/18 4:59pm

Mormon kids can function in general society. Amish kids can't.

jrj84105

1/17/18 11:30pm

As the world becomes more corrupt

Borg

1/17/18 1:35pm

Our recent investment in athletic facilities says otherwise

JKLCoug

1/17/18 2:02pm

I hope you're right... Just think in the big scheme of things,

Borg

1/17/18 3:02pm

Your friend is probably trusting his ref eyes . . . I've been told they are

TBabyCougs

1/17/18 1:38pm

BYU Football is not going anywhere. Utah State would die before BYU.

andrewg3

1/17/18 1:45pm

Lol why do people keep bringing up utah state in this thread?

RdF3

1/17/18 2:03pm

People who don't see this being a real possibility are just kidding themselves.

TutumTeRoboreReddam

1/17/18 2:05pm

I'm literally laughing out loud; my response

1/17/18 2:07pm

Please name one P5 program that has as bad of an OCT/NOV home schedule.

Blue streak

1/17/18 3:54pm

you've named the same number I come up with: ZERO.

Blue streak

1/18/18 8:24am

hold on a sec

1/18/18 10:12am

Sounds like you agree, our HOME sched in Oct/Nov is worse than every single P5.

Blue streak

1/18/18 11:31am

I say it has minimal effect on the survival of BYU

1/18/18 1:57pm

Very good possibility we be in a conference within five years

shakarocks

1/17/18 2:20pm

You need to get better friends. Your friend sounds like a clown.

Yunit

1/17/18 2:21pm

Also can you imagine going to a college that doesn't have a football team?

Yunit

1/17/18 2:22pm

RE: Also can you imagine going to a college that doesn't have a football team?

UMWolverine

1/17/18 2:33pm

Agreed, but I think most of them would prefer to be at BYU Provo.

Yunit

1/17/18 3:08pm

Because they are enrolling to take online

FanofBYU

1/18/18 12:08am

How are online courses a challenge to the Athletic program? There are

Yunit

1/18/18 8:14am

A challenge in terms of long term direction.

FanofBYU

1/18/18 11:50am

If Utah State can support a FB team after all these years then BYU will be fine.

Yunit

1/18/18 1:44pm

Maybe, but for different reasons

hms_ben

1/17/18 2:51pm

Good response.

1/17/18 3:15pm

Does your friend live in a padded room by chance?

Thug Mormons

1/17/18 2:55pm

BYU Football is so overrated as a missionary tool and I think the BOT knows it.

dreamlvr

1/17/18 3:36pm

Define 'missionary tool'. Life long member here, I leave if BYU football goes.

Blue streak

1/17/18 4:00pm

Retention tool >>>>>>>>>>>> missionary tool.

jrj84105

1/17/18 4:32pm

It sounds like you agree with me, but are arguing over semantics.

dreamlvr

1/17/18 4:39pm

Completely agree. Many times we use the term Missionary work to mean only

Blue streak

1/18/18 8:29am

Why does the percent of church members in the us matter?

cougarfann888

1/17/18 3:41pm

Take away BYU Football, and you basically nuke the entire Athletic Department budget at BYU. No Football = no BYU sports

1/17/18 3:41pm

Disagree completely

ManicBlue

1/17/18 4:04pm

Good post. Thanks for the reasoned reply. Definitely worth considering.

1/17/18 6:18pm

Francis bernard is already gone

1/17/18 4:05pm

FB = football.

crazY

1/17/18 4:07pm

haha i was kidding

1/17/18 9:41pm

I know.

crazY

1/17/18 10:33pm

Your friend has no clue.

Thrill

1/17/18 4:07pm

Not buying it. We wouldn't have forked out the dough for Detmer, Grimes etc

1/17/18 4:32pm

Ya I believe sports could be nixed in that time frame

Y4LYFE

1/17/18 4:43pm

BYU FB will be gone when fans/boosters lose interest/give up

jkccoug

1/17/18 4:55pm

Is your friend a Ute fan?

1/17/18 6:06pm

No. He's a BYU fan.

1/17/18 6:07pm

Interesting. Last name Whittingham? 😉

1/17/18 6:13pm

How did you guess!?! Dang, you're pretty good at this.

1/17/18 6:15pm

All that means

Heinz57

1/17/18 6:37pm

#1 is the only one that wasn't true 50 years ago.

CougarThug

1/17/18 8:06pm

Yes! I can look forward to American Ride Reruns on Saturdays now!

tjngirlz

1/17/18 8:20pm

And reruns of extinct and Granite Flats. Two

FanofBYU

1/18/18 12:15am

so where does this guy live? Utah? Elsewhere?

TheAirForceCoug

1/17/18 8:40pm

This has been wishful thinking by yewt fans for decades now.

Conan

1/18/18 12:02am

obviously, your friend is a numb nut

mindzeYe

1/18/18 1:30am

Your friend sure seems to have the talking points of every Yewt fan I've

1/18/18 7:25am

BYU football is in a better position financially, competitely, and future

Lance71

1/18/18 9:36am

Junk like this shouldn't be in the top 10.

k2coug

1/18/18 7:23pm

Ummmm... cool. Conspiracy theories are cool.

Circaman12

1/18/18 7:56pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad