Good not great

Report problem with this ad

Feb 18, 2018
7:54:32pm

donnerstag All-American

Good not great

but the football teams lower the bar to get in, so they can be great at football.

Report problem with this ad

donnerstag

Bio page: donnerstag
Joined: Feb 22, 2005
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 38,910 (680 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: If your son was a 4-5* FB player this year w/ STRONG aspirations and potential to go to the NFL...

Traveshamockery

2/18/18 5:52pm

I'd have a hard time saying no to Chris Peterson or David Shaw.

VenetianCougar

2/18/18 5:53pm

Good coaches, but I'd go P4. Dabo would be #1 option

Ulysses14

2/18/18 5:56pm

I have a west coast bias (and in particular a UW bias) but that'd be great too.

VenetianCougar

2/18/18 7:47pm

Yep Coach Pete develops talent

Coogar2

2/19/18 12:06pm

His choice of any top 20 program? Is this a trick question?

mosterlow

2/18/18 5:57pm

Offers from the usual top 20 programs.

Traveshamockery

2/18/18 5:58pm

if his goal is the nfl, I would encourage him to chose a top 20 school that he

mosterlow

2/18/18 6:06pm

The spot thst fits his style the best and would give him the best chance.

blueaussie

2/18/18 5:58pm

I wonder what percentage of 4 or 5 * players who don't go to a UT college go inactive.

HarlemCoug

2/18/18 5:58pm

A high percentage

donnerstag

2/18/18 6:01pm

Even at Stanford it is high

BountifulCoug5

2/18/18 9:27pm

please tell Bountiful Coug. U are wrong. 6 RM's- I heard all striving @Stanford

Swishfromdeep3

2/19/18 12:23am

Going to be very hard to reach level desired if we don't get some to come...

coug10278

2/18/18 5:58pm

There are too many doofuses on the top teams like USC, Alabama, Ohio State

donnerstag

2/18/18 5:59pm

All those schools you mentioned are good academically aren't they?

Pasadena

2/18/18 7:42pm

Good not great

donnerstag

2/18/18 7:54pm

But better than BYU?

Pasadena

2/18/18 8:24pm

This seems contradictory

JadonY

2/19/18 7:42am

What I am saying is that many athletes who go to top schools

donnerstag

2/19/18 9:54am

I’d want him to pick Notre Dame

SL12

2/18/18 6:01pm

Great school, but it almost has no LDS support system

donnerstag

2/18/18 6:03pm

I have three nephews who have all attended there on academic scholarships who

wcj99

2/18/18 7:30pm

It's different if you're married

donnerstag

2/18/18 7:51pm

I dunno, heard Math and Science nerds at ND looooooooooooove to party...

icecougar

2/18/18 7:52pm

Not true. Just not the place to find a spouse.

Cougstreak

2/18/18 9:47pm

No singles ward = dealbreaker for most kids

donnerstag

2/18/18 10:00pm

First I'd let the kid decide

shakarocks

2/18/18 6:06pm

Of course. That's why I said opinion.

Traveshamockery

2/18/18 6:07pm

There is much I cannot stand about the U, but frankly, all of these viable

cajuncoug

2/18/18 9:55pm

I don't think the BYU experience is what it was

shakarocks

2/18/18 10:16pm

Great post

JadonY

2/19/18 7:57am

It’s a funny question because as a parent there are many experiences I would

BYUCLA

2/18/18 6:07pm

The priority for all my kids is not shortterm fame and fortune. As a parent my highest priority is for them to develop

Zenoch

2/18/18 8:06pm

BYU IF (big IF) I have a reasonable amount of confidence in the coach.

WizeGuise

2/18/18 6:13pm

I don’t think this is a fair poll, because I wouldn’t “recommend” just one. I’d

ray ray

2/18/18 6:17pm

Alabama, Stanford, UCLA, UW, WSU

BIG XII Coug

2/18/18 6:22pm

Blue goggles off...that’s funny

gwill

2/18/18 6:23pm

So...a guy like Fred Warner who is a projected 2nd round pick?

Thrill

2/18/18 6:27pm

Well I hope the people who are saying BYU have a bunch of 4 and 5 star kids

Cougarealist

2/18/18 6:30pm

Yeah, Ziggy would've had a much higher draft status elsewhere

Carlos E. Queso

2/18/18 9:26pm

Meh

shakarocks

2/18/18 10:18pm

How do you get much higher than #5 in 1st round? Remarkable w/ so little exp -

MajorPain

2/19/18 1:06pm

It’s the coaches and staffs job to sell me not going elsewhere and

Gerald-DeGroot

2/18/18 6:31pm

Given their track record in the past 18 months

BIG XII Coug

2/18/18 6:32pm

Or needs to end.

Gerald-DeGroot

2/18/18 6:33pm

A fourth option should be to advise him to do what he thinks would be best.

Ned Schneebly

2/18/18 6:38pm

That's a given.

Traveshamockery

2/18/18 6:38pm

I wouldn't send any such son to BYU right now. In Bronco days, I'd have sent LB,

Cashmeousside

2/18/18 6:42pm

Sadly, it probably wouldn't be BYU right now

Byu_1988

2/18/18 7:17pm

Honestly, it doesn't matter if he has NFL aspirations and is that good.

JamesWestfall

2/18/18 7:59pm

Stanford, then BYU.

Junior Deputy

2/18/18 8:01pm

Depends on which position he played.

zerome4sooners

2/18/18 8:02pm

If you’re truly good, you’ll get solid play time at BYU and get noticed

Heath Squashwell

2/18/18 8:50pm

BYU rarely to never gets these guys.

Countcougula

2/18/18 9:11pm

BYU: Great education, big pool of females to find a wife and unique environment

cougarnw

2/18/18 9:15pm

This is the only logic that makes sense to me, well put.

Pretorian

2/19/18 8:22am

That's only a portion of what athletes look at

shakarocks

2/19/18 11:54am

How is the third option even a thought to 19 of you.

Pobs

2/18/18 9:27pm

their board sucks so they have to read ours....

HarlemCoug

2/18/18 10:17pm

RE: their board sucks so they have to read ours....

displacedute

2/19/18 12:20am

Amen

Pretorian

2/19/18 8:22am

The player will make NFL with work, not the school.

Count Cougar

2/18/18 9:38pm

That's not entirely true. Playing with better talent around you helps a player

BigBrotherUte

2/18/18 10:24pm

Not to mention being taught good technique

displacedute

2/19/18 12:21am

Just saw a mock draft with Josh Allen from Wyoming going #2

Count Cougar

2/20/18 2:11pm

Priority Number 1 would be to get my son on a mission, then ...

sandiegocgrfan

2/18/18 10:48pm

BYU isn't just a school

Bob Vance

2/18/18 10:57pm

What do you mean "blue goggles off"? There's nothing outside BYU — NOTHING.

ArchbishopMitty

2/18/18 11:32pm

Stanford... the rest aren't even close... but after that it would be

jomo

2/19/18 1:02am

Any BYU fan that marked "UofU" in the poll should be disbarred from CB and have

CObluezone

2/19/18 4:37am

RE: Any BYU fan that marked "UofU" in the poll should be disbarred from CB and

displacedute

2/19/18 6:19am

He should be disbarred.

CObluezone

2/19/18 8:49am

Would've said Stanford...

wilsdad

2/19/18 4:59am

To me Stanford is the best the secular world has to offer, from both a football

Junior Deputy

2/19/18 7:19am

I think culturally I find more in common with the South

wilsdad

2/19/18 8:46am

Some kids will want BYU regardless, others will go wherever they feel comfortabl

Cyclogist

2/19/18 7:51am

it would depend on what my son wanted to major in. I am that guy who emphasizes

DJROSS

2/19/18 8:11am

i wouldn’t want my kid to go to the nfl with out the foundation of the BYU

Pretorian

2/19/18 9:22am

I'd probably go a more conservative route....get into the best undergrad

Nat Gas Man

2/19/18 10:07am

does Stanford MBA allow football players?

HarlemCoug

2/19/18 10:16am

not sure...it would be weird to not allow those that can do the work and grades

Nat Gas Man

2/20/18 1:54pm

I used to say BYU but can’t with Kalani as coach. He is killing talent like

Coogar2

2/19/18 12:11pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad