You are blaming a decade of disappointment on one football player? Yes, you are

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 10, 2020
11:31:09am

TailgateU Walk-on

You are blaming a decade of disappointment on one football player? Yes, you are

wrong.

Report problem with this ad

TailgateU

Bio page: TailgateU
Joined: Aug 16, 2017
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 10,696 (6 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Cougarboard, am I wrong? Heaps and LP3 set back our football and basketball team

buckeyecougarguy

1/9/20 12:39pm

Yes you are wrong

TNT

1/9/20 12:41pm

*TJ Haws. And very wrong.

PGVikingDad

1/9/20 12:42pm

already corrected

buckeyecougarguy

1/9/20 12:43pm

Tanner Mangum needs to be given some credit. He is statistically the

1/9/20 12:43pm

There is an honorable mention to be had there. Had he kept up his freshman

buckeyecougarguy

1/9/20 1:37pm

You realize he was benched last year by Kalani, right?

MaxxPower

1/9/20 6:01pm

No he wasn’t. He got injured.

1/9/20 8:39pm

Nope. You're thinking of 2017. He was benched after USU his senior year for Wilson

MaxxPower

1/12/20 2:35pm

The Heaps effect coincided with a change at OC from Anae to Doman...

PJMort

1/9/20 12:44pm

And what caused the Mangum and Wilson declines in their second years?

SandYFan

1/9/20 12:49pm

RE: And what caused the Mangum and Wilson declines in their second years?

PJMort

1/9/20 3:27pm

yeah there have been some problems at offensive coordinator outside of R Anae.

buckeyecougarguy

1/9/20 1:41pm

Good questions. Experience is important. Skilled players also.

PJMort

1/9/20 1:54pm

KVN doesn't come to BYU if not for Heaps- Mika and TJ Haws have been

acougfan

1/9/20 12:45pm

I just look at what happened post Max Hall and it was supposed to be Heaps

buckeyecougarguy

1/9/20 1:54pm

Nope it is the curse on Max Hall

LongtimeUtahfan

1/9/20 2:56pm

for football the only answer is KS imo.

cougfanz

1/9/20 12:45pm

Disagree. Fan hype/expectations don't directly affect the program. If a coach

Thrill

1/9/20 12:46pm

So was it more of a failure to develop him from a coaching standpoint or was it

buckeyecougarguy

1/9/20 2:20pm

I think some kids with access to private coaches reach their peak sooner. Not

Thrill

1/9/20 6:32pm

we had a high point thanks to Jimmer otherwise BYU basketball has been pretty

franklyvulgar

1/9/20 12:46pm

I think Rose took a dive, not the players.

Adwight

1/9/20 12:48pm

Rose was very overrated. Bronco also set the program back a decade at least.

TheWoodman

1/9/20 1:00pm

Kilane Salami

Cougs'16

1/9/20 1:46pm

Heap, Haws, and Mika did nothing to directly hurt any of the programs.

mudpupper

1/9/20 12:52pm

yeah i guess my beef with LP3 is Emery, but i feel strongly that Mika should

buckeyecougarguy

1/9/20 2:25pm

I agree, especially with the LP3.

Count Cougar

1/9/20 4:12pm

Not getting into a P5 conference when BYU was the best choice and only had

blackshirts

1/9/20 4:18pm

You are blaming a decade of disappointment on one football player? Yes, you are

TailgateU

1/10/20 11:31am

I'm saying him not reaching his potential really dug a hole for BYU that they

buckeyecougarguy

1/10/20 2:33pm

If we are so negatively affected by a single busted player, we didn't have much

TailgateU

1/10/20 2:40pm

i'm not so sure. I think its entirely possible our coaching staff is different

buckeyecougarguy

1/10/20 3:08pm

If I were a potential recruit, fan opinions like yours would drive me away.

TailgateU

1/11/20 2:54pm

I said he had an effect. All players have a stake in the future of the program.

buckeyecougarguy

1/12/20 1:09am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad