It’s actually a great question for someone under the age of 44 or so

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jul 20, 2021
8:07:08pm

Medute Truly Addicted User

It’s actually a great question for someone under the age of 44 or so

Would you rather have a national championship that you have no memory of vs what Utah did.

Personally, as a 41-year-old man, I would pick Utah because I actually enjoyed in those moments. I went to both the Fiesta Bowl and the Sugar Bowl. I went to all the home games in 2004. Those were really special years for me. I have no memory from when I was four years old.

So it just depends on how much you value having a trophy.

Report problem with this ad

Medute

Bio page: Medute
Joined: Jun 29, 2010
Last login: Apr 25, 2024
Total posts: 17,486 (1,108 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Unpopular opinion time:

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:04pm

Interesting. And yet BYU has a trophy...

panacablue

7/20/21 7:06pm

The CFB system allowed it in 1984. If that exact same BYU team won those exact

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:07pm

Someday Utah may have some national respect to get the trophy.

jrifkin48

7/20/21 7:15pm

Nothing wrong with being a realist and accepting this truth

Medute

7/20/21 8:02pm

We were the best team in CFB in 1984, at least according to the system for

Corn Pop

7/21/21 10:50am

Did that make you feel better, to finally get that off your chest?

LifeLongLakerFan

7/20/21 7:06pm

RE: Unpopular opinion time:

7/20/21 7:07pm

RE: Unpopular opinion time:

crack

7/20/21 7:07pm

I think winning a championship is more impressive than not winning one.

ochobeeguy

7/20/21 7:07pm

RE: I think winning a championship is more impressive than not winning one.

The Dark Knight

7/20/21 7:15pm

BYU was awarded a championship. The combination of going undefeated and the

Dread Pirate Westley

7/20/21 7:20pm

You didn't change my mind.

ochobeeguy

7/20/21 7:22pm

Didn't expect to. Doesn't mean I'm wrong.

Dread Pirate Westley

7/20/21 7:26pm

Your last point doesn't make it any less of a championship

The Dark Knight

7/20/21 7:37pm

I didn't say it did. But the fact is that BSU and Utah did every bit as much as

Dread Pirate Westley

7/20/21 7:44pm

...but what if the other team played BETTER...then Boise would have lost.

The Dark Knight

7/20/21 7:51pm

But that's not what I'm saying. In their respective years BYU, Utah and BSU all

Dread Pirate Westley

7/20/21 8:07pm

The perfect storm in 1984 was that every ranked team had 2 losses or more except

Greg4BYU

7/20/21 8:17pm

Yep...everything just fell into place. Even though I'm not a BYU fan, I was and

Dread Pirate Westley

7/20/21 8:21pm

What's the matter rocker? Cat got your tongue? Why do you have a problem with

Dread Pirate Westley

7/20/21 8:33pm

RE: I didn't say it did. But the fact is that BSU and Utah did every bit as

mobius

7/20/21 7:51pm

This could set the record for the most thumbs down ever.

crack

7/20/21 7:08pm

The only difference between what we did and what Utah’s done twice is the timing

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:10pm

please remove "we"--you have lost that privilege

Incentivize

7/20/21 7:14pm

No. The only difference is BYU wasn't given the chance to play a top team in a

crack

7/20/21 7:14pm

The other part of the timing was the other undefeated teams in 2004. That’s

Scratch

7/20/21 7:18pm

I hate to agree with you, but I have to.

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:20pm

But the fact is they didn't.

The Dark Knight

7/20/21 7:33pm

Each year experts voted on a #1 team. That didn't change.

The Dark Knight

7/20/21 7:18pm

If I remember right, Whittingham didn't even vote Utah #1 before the Sugar Bowl.

crack

7/20/21 7:20pm

The experts pick the top 4. They decide it on the field.

Dread Pirate Westley

7/20/21 7:23pm

Fair point, I edited my post. Comparing the years in question hadn't changed.

The Dark Knight

7/20/21 7:24pm

Oops. I thought you responded to my post above about the coach's poll.

crack

7/20/21 7:29pm

Letting a poll or committee choose a small select number of teams to compete

BYUFam1

7/21/21 10:35am

We need a worst post of the day system

backprop

7/20/21 7:09pm

You mean unpopular, stupid, non-sensical, uninformed, laughable, head scratching

kansascougar

7/20/21 7:10pm

Ignore what the AP poll voters voted in 1984 and the two teams accomplished the

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:11pm

FYI, Utah has never been ranked #1 by AP

7/20/21 7:18pm

Your using SOS as the main point of your argument, but the eras were so completely different

Adrielle

7/20/21 7:10pm

Reported

Grit for Brains

7/20/21 7:11pm

RE: Unpopular opinion time:

byujacob

7/20/21 7:11pm

The only thup you're getting is from DPW. Does that answer your question?

byujacob

7/20/21 7:12pm

Wrong Board- try a ute fan board

acougfan

7/20/21 7:14pm

RE: Unpopular opinion time:

Tare

7/20/21 7:14pm

To add to this - If the roles were reversed you all know for a fact BYU fans

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:14pm

RE: To add to this - If the roles were reversed you all know for a fact BYU fans

acougfan

7/20/21 7:15pm

Oh my word. You're doubling down on it.

byujacob

7/20/21 7:15pm

RE: To add to this - If the roles were reversed you all know for a fact BYU fans

7/20/21 7:18pm

Hey guys! Since you couldn't put multiple thumb's dwn on the OP, here's another

whirl

7/21/21 9:16am

If the roles reversed only one team would have a Natty... Love having a Natty

NYC and Japan

7/21/21 10:10am

What's that? I can't hear you over the shine of the trophy in Legacy Hall...

The Dark Knight

7/20/21 7:14pm

I love that we have it, I really do. And I wouldn’t trade if for a BCS win.

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:18pm

But that isn't the only difference. You are oversimplifying.

The Dark Knight

7/20/21 7:22pm

This doesn’t actually make any sense

Alpi Gusto

7/20/21 7:31pm

RE: This doesn’t actually make any sense

The Dark Knight

7/20/21 7:34pm

Any honest Ute fan would trade both of theirs for our 1.

7/20/21 7:16pm

It’s actually a great question for someone under the age of 44 or so

Medute

7/20/21 8:07pm

That’s a fair point. I am just comparing the accomplishments against each other,

7/20/21 8:15pm

You should change your name to Whittingham’sAnus

7/20/21 7:17pm

RE: You should change your name to Whittingham’sAnus

IAmACougarManSir....

7/21/21 9:00am

Uh oh, someones ute is showing.

panacablue

7/20/21 7:18pm

Good fortune is when preparation meets opportunity...

icecougar

7/20/21 7:19pm

Well, that take just ruined you on Cougarboard

Carnac

7/20/21 7:21pm

Nope, I’ll be attending 8 BYU games this year in my Royal Blue

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:22pm

Just be proud of the trophy.

Carnac

7/20/21 7:29pm

I am proud of it. I love that we won it, and hope we can win another.

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:32pm

Starting now and forever more, you will be “that guy.”

garyfan

7/20/21 7:21pm

I don’t really care how I’m perceived here 🤷‍♂️

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:24pm

“Unpopular” is a slight understatement

7/20/21 7:24pm

And people say Im the closet Ute fan. Sheesh.

Backcountry

7/20/21 7:29pm

I legitimately hate Utah, my post history would prove that.

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 7:34pm

Im with you man. I used to despise them. Now Im totally apathetic.

Backcountry

7/20/21 7:43pm

There are some things you just don’t say. Even if you think it, you don’t say it

Kavorka

7/20/21 7:31pm

UPI also had the power to declare Nat champion in 1984... also chose BYU

Greg4BYU

7/20/21 7:32pm

RE: Unpopular opinion time:

Bluedarts

7/20/21 7:32pm

This is a reasonable take given to the wrong audience. Courageous move.

7/20/21 7:37pm

👎

7/20/21 7:37pm

'04 Utah was much more impressive than '08 Utah

Greg4BYU

7/20/21 7:41pm

And yet, there were still 3 teams better in 2004

DrYfire

7/20/21 8:34pm

Well, your vote doesn’t count. All the voters that mattered disagree with you.

canofpicante

7/20/21 7:43pm

User notes updated.

kccougar

7/20/21 7:48pm

Why do you even care enough to come up with it and spend time posting it

7/20/21 8:08pm

This is a BYU football board

Backcountry

7/20/21 8:13pm

You would defend him. Ha

7/20/21 8:20pm

Because he's right, Lip!

Backcountry

7/20/21 8:44pm

In your opinion

slatecoug

7/21/21 5:23am

Those Oklahoma teams that won 55 straight games weren’t that good. They would never do that in today’s game. Same logic

SpiffCoug

7/20/21 8:30pm

After a troll post like this why doesn’t everyone just put this guy on Ignore?

IgnoreThem

7/20/21 8:44pm

Board name indeed checks out.

7/20/21 8:48pm

That really is the reason for my name. To eventually get people to ignore trolls

IgnoreThem

7/20/21 9:09pm

Except that’s not what I am. It’s a legit opinion, and I gave arguments.

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/20/21 9:14pm

We won both the AP and Coaches poll in 1984.

Bert609

7/20/21 8:57pm

Anyone unsure if this is a good post just needs to look at the POTDs and thumbs

7/21/21 6:39am

Crap like this post deserve a lifetime ban.

whirl

7/21/21 9:16am

I enjoyed watching Utah demolish Alabama. I hope they lose every game this year

HenderCoug

7/21/21 10:03am

Except BYU was on a 24 game win streak and was the only undefeated team in the

Fdnman

7/21/21 10:22am

That is part of the problem with CFB, what you have done in prior seasons should

ZacSeljaas'Stache

7/21/21 10:24am

Partially is that a large part of being ranked at the top depends on where you

Fdnman

7/21/21 10:29am

#13 after week one

Fdnman

7/21/21 10:34am

Interesting that Utah was preseason #20 and didn't break #13 until week #6

Fdnman

7/21/21 10:37am

It also breaks down the narrative that the teams did the same thing.

The Dark Knight

7/21/21 11:21am

Not to mention USC was #1 in the preseason and never lost...no chance for Utah

Fdnman

7/21/21 10:43am

Reverse roles and BYU is probably in the Big 12 and Utah may or may not be PAC12

NYC and Japan

7/21/21 11:43am

LOL. Utah needed so many lucky bounces to go their way in 2008...

7/21/21 2:12pm

You may want to go revisit some of BYU's games from 1984.

Scratch

7/21/21 2:20pm

I guess that is sort of my point...the 08 season wasn't this grand thing way

7/21/21 2:27pm

It might be just as impressive; but it's still not as meaningful

krindorr

7/21/21 2:42pm

And yet their teams still would have lost to the ‘96 and ‘84 BYU teams.

Bin01015

7/21/21 4:11pm

6-5* Michigan team. Why does everyone say 6-6...because it makes it look worse

7/21/21 5:55pm

It's pretty common to describe yes with their end-of-season record

krindorr

7/21/21 6:13pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad