I didn't tell anyone to stop reasoning. Quit making things up.
I just said that my reasoning fits known facts that are well documented. And it fits actual statements by both coaches and the AD. In other words I base my reasoning on reality and you have no way to refute that.
Ice's (and apparently your) reasoning requires you to call all three men, men who have shown a great deal of integrity over the years, liars. Hmmmmm...... Which line of reasoning seems more reasonable?
Your right. I am too much - for you. LOL