My Account
Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jun 16, 2019
8:34
:37
am
Adrielle
Lone Biker of the Apocalypse
I still think of Utah has an advantage at the RB position
With the grad transfers, and with Katoa, and the others coming back, I think the RB group is much closer to Utah.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Adrielle
Previous username
deckard667
Bio page
Adrielle
Joined
Sep 10, 2013
Last login
May 7, 2024
Total posts
36,215 (5,319 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
BYU v Utah by position group
Alsippi89
6/15/19 7:09pm
Disagree on QB. I would like Wilson to be on Utah's team, but Huntley is better
ALUF 1990
6/15/19 7:22pm
Yep. At this point, Huntley is more proven.
Cougar76
6/15/19 7:27pm
Well, Wilson was a true freshman
I'mBatman
6/15/19 7:28pm
Seriously stop with the OL overrated stuff. There's no evidence of it.
Lip Gallagher
6/15/19 8:45pm
yah they were awesome last year
I'mBatman
6/16/19 4:08pm
Inconsistent? Yes.
puntersarepeople
6/16/19 5:02pm
Best of any team in Utah since 2004?
Bossk82
6/15/19 7:35pm
Then Utah went on to lose the PAC title and Bowl game. Hmm.
SaintGeorgeYFan
6/15/19 7:42pm
And BYU crushed the mighty Western Mich
DocPimp
6/16/19 12:37am
Utah still lost twice on the big stage... they continue
SaintGeorgeYFan
6/16/19 1:20am
If BYU can point to injuries, to discount their loss to Utah, then surely Utah can point to the fact that their starting
whitey1980
6/16/19 1:27am
Did I point to injuries? Nope. Thanks for chiming in though.
SaintGeorgeYFan
6/17/19 2:53am
1. No, but lots of other people have. And I think it's a fair point. I also think it's a fair point for Utah. *I*
whitey1980
6/17/19 3:08am
Bless your heart Whitey... you really tried. You're a good Ute apologist.
SaintGeorgeYFan
6/17/19 11:15pm
Thank you. That's why I come here.
whitey1980
6/17/19 11:45pm
News flash.
DocPimp
6/16/19 8:56am
Yet here you are on BYU's board. You don't have a Ute board to go to?
SaintGeorgeYFan
6/17/19 2:52am
To answer your question, because it’s fantastic rivalry.
DocPimp
6/17/19 9:26am
What happened to "next-guy-up" mantra? Wittingham preaches that...no excuse.
SaintGeorgeYFan
6/17/19 2:58am
I’m sure the mighty utes would have beaten us with their 5th and 6th string rb
Cougar76
6/17/19 6:17am
100% agree with you
DocPimp
6/17/19 12:58pm
Funny, my Utah friend was freaking out about how awful Huntley was last year.
tawillin
6/15/19 8:01pm
Your opinion is wrong. Wilson didn't only play in the games he won, he also
UberDeek
6/15/19 8:18pm
Any BYU fan who watched both would pick Wilson.
displacedute
6/15/19 10:16pm
Any regular person would say Huntley is extremely overrated by Athlon
puntersarepeople
6/15/19 10:19pm
You guys keep saying "everyone knows Wilson is better".
displacedute
6/15/19 10:22pm
Our Scott Mitchell? Good one... You funny
UberDeek
6/15/19 11:49pm
It’s not nonsense at all
puntersarepeople
6/16/19 8:57am
Sure, if you're a BYU fan.
displacedute
6/16/19 9:23am
Or if you look at advanced stats 😂
puntersarepeople
6/18/19 10:08am
And ignore SOS.
displacedute
6/18/19 10:13am
Lol find me 5 people who think that list looks legit.
Lip Gallagher
6/15/19 11:41pm
I believe it when it comes to state of Utah QBs.
displacedute
6/15/19 11:58pm
One thing I'll say about BYU vs. Utah at QB- One could make a case for either starter... BUT, the drop-off at #2 QB
whitey1980
6/16/19 12:19am
You are absolutely right...
DocPimp
6/16/19 12:40am
Huntley sucked against ASU
midlandcoug
6/15/19 8:22pm
It's not close at all? You sure? I mean, Huntley has two straight years of
Lip Gallagher
6/15/19 8:39pm
Wilson’s best game was against Utah
puntersarepeople
6/15/19 8:50pm
Wilson’s best game was against W. Mich IMO
zerome4sooners
6/15/19 8:55pm
QBR disagrees
puntersarepeople
6/16/19 9:35am
Who is Patrick Mahoney?
studmuffin85
6/15/19 11:23pm
I think what any list like this misses is simply “game changers”
Medute
6/15/19 7:55pm
Since when is Tupai a top pick (or a pick at all) in next year's draft?
Lip Gallagher
6/15/19 8:36pm
Yeah, Paulo and Bowen probably higher rated than Tupai right now
Medute
6/15/19 8:46pm
I haven't heard amazing things about Ford and maybe Paulo?
Lip Gallagher
6/15/19 8:55pm
Since our scores are usually less than four points
D.T. Survivor
6/15/19 9:38pm
Utah has better WR, but the rest are reasonable.
lilpenny
6/15/19 8:51pm
Romney could change that
puntersarepeople
6/15/19 8:55pm
Utah having the speedy deep threat sets them apart. And BYU still won't have
Lip Gallagher
6/15/19 9:01pm
The thing about these comparisons is they assume the best for your own team’s
Scratch
6/16/19 9:46am
That's fun and all talking about depth at Utah at WR, but now realize that
Lip Gallagher
6/16/19 10:24am
I'm well aware of Romney's health issues and that's why the comparison makes
Scratch
6/16/19 10:35am
Then your boy should stand out if he's that good. Because he doesn't have
Lip Gallagher
6/16/19 10:41am
You're underestimating how good the guys in front of him are. They're not world
Scratch
6/16/19 10:57am
No I'm not. I'm saying if he's as good as you guys think, he should demand his
Lip Gallagher
6/16/19 11:19am
“Your boy”? Are you serious? You should probably think a little
Jdoc
6/17/19 11:37am
Lighten up Francis. Don't start that Westbrook stuff.
Lip Gallagher
6/17/19 11:45am
It’s never ok to use the word “boy” when referring to an
Jdoc
6/17/19 2:09pm
Don't start. Go away Ute.
Lip Gallagher
6/17/19 2:40pm
I started. Do you really think the use of the term "boy" is appropriate when
Jdoc
6/17/19 3:03pm
Awful. Just awful. Greetings and salutations to all your Dixieland folk.
UNHuskerCoug
6/19/19 8:44am
Utah wr’s are absolutely more athletic and explosive
deliciousmocha
6/16/19 12:44pm
When will Covey be ready to play?
Littlerich
6/15/19 9:00pm
Nobody knows.
displacedute
6/15/19 10:23pm
If Covey plays he likely won't be 100%
bscores2
6/16/19 10:54am
I really have never seen why people say Covey is so good.... he’s good but I’d
Pretorian
6/16/19 1:06pm
Covey plays with a ton of heart.
bscores2
6/16/19 1:46pm
FWIW, Phil Steele has BYU's quarterbacks and offensive line ahead of Utah
donnerstag
6/15/19 9:40pm
I thought Steele had Utah at #8 in the nation?
displacedute
6/15/19 10:05pm
Our RBs will be top 60 no doubt, especially with that OL
Pretorian
6/16/19 1:07pm
I think it's important to give some context to the separation.
displacedute
6/15/19 10:15pm
Some of these should be TBD
puntersarepeople
6/15/19 10:23pm
You definitely have goggles. Utah's 3 DTs are all better than Tonga?
Lip Gallagher
6/15/19 11:55pm
Kaufusi had 50 tackles last year.
displacedute
6/16/19 7:35am
You can't go off of numbers alone. Numbers don't say anything about
Lip Gallagher
6/16/19 8:30am
Bowen started at Penn State for two years, and Bernard started at BYU.
displacedute
6/16/19 9:31am
Those are very red goggles. Very very red
Cougar76
6/15/19 11:57pm
Hifo > Covey
Pretorian
6/16/19 1:14pm
Uh, no. In every game he's played, the announcers are constantly amazed by Covey's skills, speed, slipperiness,
whitey1980
6/16/19 3:10pm
Hifo wasn’t great but he’s solid
puntersarepeople
6/16/19 3:17pm
Health is a big part of it but basing any insight on that on
Pretorian
6/16/19 3:55pm
I doubt anyone is "amazed" but he's good and it's unfortunate Utah sucks
Lip Gallagher
6/16/19 3:41pm
Did you see the Wisky game? And intelligence, curious how you’ve deducted that?
Pretorian
6/16/19 3:53pm
Sick burn, dude.
whitey1980
6/16/19 5:13pm
How could Covey big a bigger national star than Hifo when Utah is not on
Pretorian
6/16/19 8:27pm
If Covey was at BYU, he'd be your best receiver, your kick/punt returner, and your 2nd best QB.
whitey1980
6/17/19 3:14am
So says mr Ute fan whitey 1980 on the BYU fan board... #1 source of unbiased
Pretorian
6/17/19 6:07am
Huntley is more proven.
Gerald-DeGroot
6/15/19 10:17pm
Athlon ranked each conference in 7 categories
whitey1980
6/16/19 12:10am
TE isn’t even close
puntersarepeople
6/16/19 9:03am
That Athlon QB ranking is bogus. You look at the numbers, what matters,
Lip Gallagher
6/16/19 11:29am
Let's talk about injuries...
whitey1980
6/16/19 4:27pm
Jaren Hall is more talented than Shelley
puntersarepeople
6/17/19 2:20pm
I wonder if Jaren is as good of a QB as true freshman Zach Wilson
Dr T-bone
6/17/19 2:46pm
I'm looking forward to your QBs winning the next 4 Heisman trophies
displacedute
6/17/19 3:09pm
If they don't go to the NFL before then
Dr T-bone
6/17/19 3:15pm
Classic. The #s that don’t agree with my opinion are bogus
UNHuskerCoug
6/17/19 1:13pm
It'll be interesting to see how good the new BYU RBs perform
Richbyu
6/16/19 12:14am
I still think of Utah has an advantage at the RB position
Adrielle
6/16/19 8:34am
We see this exercise every year. It's interesting, however...
lbmango
6/16/19 10:41am
The line is Utah by 6 right now, so it would definitely be an upset
displacedute
6/16/19 10:47am
This is very frustrating bc this looks to be the best BYU team in years but the
Pretorian
6/16/19 1:17pm
If by "years" you mean "three" then yes, you're correct
BeardedSpock
6/16/19 2:06pm
BOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!
bscores2
6/16/19 2:20pm
I actually disagree with this a bunch
puntersarepeople
6/16/19 3:20pm
I love how your list is a bunch of "if only" mentions, rather than real outcome.
Lip Gallagher
6/16/19 3:32pm
9-3 team could get a ranking with a bowl win
puntersarepeople
6/16/19 3:36pm
Your foundation seems to be a healthy Taysom... I don’t really disagree but how
Pretorian
6/16/19 3:59pm
Tonga and Bushman> KVN and Taysom
puntersarepeople
6/16/19 5:03pm
RE: Tonga and Bushman> KVN and Taysom
displacedute
6/16/19 5:16pm
I really hope you’re right
Pretorian
6/16/19 8:35pm
You forgot the Coaches. That one goes to Utah
TunaNoCrust
6/16/19 6:39pm
That one is a little obvious at this point
Pretorian
6/16/19 8:34pm
True. But as. BYU fan I feel so much more confident in Grimes based on 1
Cougar76
6/16/19 8:37pm
I'll take a stab at it
Tj_utefan
6/16/19 7:09pm
RE: I'll take a stab at it
Lip Gallagher
6/16/19 7:54pm
It’s not lee as much as Gonwoloko, unless he really did go to CB?
Pretorian
6/16/19 8:33pm
Wow this is awful. Somehow Huntley gets no credit from BYU fans. Most pundits
BigBrotherUte
6/17/19 11:25am
haha Huntley isn't a top 20 QB, and he's going to end up maybe 5th in the
Lip Gallagher
6/17/19 11:43am
Lol, look I get where your coming from. It's got to be frustrating to have a
BigBrotherUte
6/18/19 3:00pm
RE: Lol, look I get where your coming from. It's got to be frustrating to have a
Lip Gallagher
6/19/19 6:14pm
Comparing individual position groups is stupid
puntersarepeople
6/19/19 7:15pm
Shelley? 😂😂😂
puntersarepeople
6/17/19 12:06pm
Yes well Shelley did beat Wilson head to head
Thlete
6/18/19 1:01am
Not individually
puntersarepeople
6/18/19 7:14am
Which QB led their offense to more points? How about net points?
BigBrotherUte
6/18/19 3:03pm
Interesting take
Thlete
6/18/19 3:12pm
Pretty close except the guy going against a better defense had 1.5 times more
puntersarepeople
6/18/19 4:45pm
You're right about all of that, so the question comes down to whether the better
Scratch
6/18/19 4:54pm
Ill give it a go
kolt7
6/17/19 2:27pm
RE: Ill give it a go
Lip Gallagher
6/17/19 2:45pm
RE: Ill give it a go
kolt7
6/17/19 9:26pm
''unanumasy''???
whitey1980
6/17/19 10:22pm
This is why I should never type on my phone
kolt7
6/17/19 11:56pm
It seriously took me 5 minutes to figure out what you meant. I sounded it out. (Ooh-nuh Noo-mah-see.) I looked it up. I
whitey1980
6/18/19 12:35am
Where did I not give him credit? I said he's likely a top 10 RB in the
Lip Gallagher
6/17/19 10:31pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad