have Huntley as a top 20 QB in the nation and top 3 in the PAC. Wilson had some good moments, but he also struggled against NMSU and has zero quality wins. At this point Shelley has proven more on a bigger stage than Wilson.
The only positions I maybe give BYU an edge are OL and TE, and TE is closer than people think. OL is also pretty close. Utah has more talent and depth on the OL but BYU has more continuity.
At every other position Utah has a clear talent and experience advantage. And it looms larger when you compare the units actually going against each other.