I think that every fan has reasons to be skeptical or ambivalent regarding Sitake and BYU football right now.
It's interesting to see how some come down on the optimistic/hopeful end of the spectrum, while others come down on the pessimistic/hopeless end.
Reality is, he has such a short track record, there's no way to know what to really expect. But we all have our reasons for seeing possibility and wanting to give him more time, or seeing disaster and wanting him gone to begin the repair.