Just as background, I started on my varsity team in high school. Nowhere near good enough to get a scholarship to play anywhere of any significance.
I would regularly play pick up ball at the RB and football players were often there playing. Austin Collie (before his mission) was very good and would easily dunk and run the floor. Most of them were obviously great athletes and would usually win on pure athleticism.
But I can remember Matt Berry playing, and he may be the worst D1 athlete I have ever seen play basketball. He didn't even look coordinated. FWIW