It was a bait and switch by Fresno and Nevada. They and USU were the schools

Feb 21, 2018
11:25:19am

NewMexiCoug All-American

wooing BYU to come join them in the WAC, then before the deal is done, they sabotage the whole thing by leaving for the MWC.

Report problem with this ad

NewMexiCoug

New username: LeGrandBleu
Bio page: NewMexiCoug
Joined: May 2, 2001
Last login: Sep 5, 2022
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

A pretty fair (IMO) read about what happened to

CMuehle

2/21/18 9:17am

BYU was shortsighted to think that the MWC wouldn't invite WAC teams to the

mudpupper

2/21/18 9:21am

yet another example of byu misreading the room.

johnnycarson

2/21/18 9:24am

You would think somebody had to bring that up.

mudpupper

2/21/18 9:27am

Seems to me it was pretty clear they knew they that would happen but the thought

RdF3

2/21/18 9:28am

It was very shortsighted of BYU. Nevada wants to be with UNLV? Fresno with SDSU?

Richbyu

2/21/18 9:36am

I think BYU overestimated its value to the WAC.

mudpupper

2/21/18 9:42am

if there is a miscalculation to be made, byu admin will make it.

johnnycarson

2/21/18 9:32am

It was a bait and switch by Fresno and Nevada. They and USU were the schools

NewMexiCoug

2/21/18 11:25am

Part of that was driven by the big money buyout clause.

Eddie

2/21/18 9:28am

Yep, $5M just wasn't enough to keep schools in place when a superior conference

Scratch

2/21/18 9:30am

FSU hadn't even signed the $5 million buyout agreement yet.

CougarThug

2/21/18 9:23pm

Classic projection. BYU wouldn't pay a $5mil fine to get out of a deal.

Art Director

2/21/18 9:41am

Why would BYU assume teams would leave the WAC?

Cougar Insider

2/21/18 9:56am

I think BYU didn't quite understand the magnitude of the changing conference

mudpupper

2/21/18 10:00am

They had a scheduling agreement with the WAC though.

Cougar Insider

2/21/18 10:01am

BYU knew what could possibly happen. It simply came down to Fresno and Nevada

Game Changer

2/21/18 1:06pm

The MWC wouldn't even invite Boise until it was too late.

boscatar

2/21/18 10:14am

^^^Bingo^^^ MWC invited BSU five days before the Pac-10 publicly invited Utah.

CougarThug

2/21/18 9:34pm

that story brought up some old memories I forgot. I still think indy

idacoug

2/21/18 9:39am

The thing that is hurting BYU Indy is not having 3-5 annual "rivalry" opponents.

Richbyu

2/21/18 9:46am

I think we should get Hawaii annually and try for TCU, Houston or SMU

boscatar

2/21/18 10:30am

BYU signed a yearly rivalry deal with Hawaii when we first went Indy

mannheimadler

2/21/18 10:41am

Wish we could revisit that. We need that deal again.

Richbyu

2/21/18 10:47am

Didn't Chow blow that up?

boscatar

2/21/18 10:58am

TCU will not agree to a long term series

CougarVeteran

2/21/18 12:03pm

I believe it was a knee jerk reaction to Utah going to the P12 and BYU and TH

franklyvulgar

2/21/18 9:50am

BYUTV and Indy were in the works well before. Utah to PAC was the catalyst

boscatar

2/21/18 10:32am

RE: that story brought up some old memories I forgot. I still think indy

CougarThug

2/21/18 9:37pm

Stupid part: Most of this could have been avoided if the MWC gave BYU third tier rights to home games

HuskerFan2

2/21/18 9:41am

Yup. It's funny they gave Boise everything they swore they'd never give BYU.

Art Director

2/21/18 9:42am

You have this wrong.

Richbyu

2/21/18 9:54am

Does point 2 really matter? They still gave in to BSU.

Scooter

2/21/18 10:19am

Yes. But I guess we could rejoin the MWC and get Boise's deal right now....

Richbyu

2/21/18 10:43am

This is how I remember it, as well.

Everyman

2/21/18 10:28am

And that was only possible because after BYU left, the Mountain folded, so no more Comcast deal.

Turnpike Lane

2/21/18 10:56am

We don't know this for sure

CougarVeteran

2/21/18 11:19am

The Comcast/CBS contract was renegotiated after it became apparent the MWC was on the verge of collapse

HuskerFan2

2/21/18 11:20am

It we renegotiated because of BYU and Utah

CougarVeteran

2/21/18 11:41am

Sounds about right.

HuskerFan2

2/21/18 1:34pm

Didnt

Coogar2

2/21/18 12:19pm

This whole timeline is complete garbage...

Coug

2/21/18 10:05am

This is much closer to the real timeline ^^^^

NewMexiCoug

2/21/18 11:13am

You make an important point that I try to remind of. BIG EAST offered.

CosmoK

2/21/18 11:20am

That Big East invite came as the result of the BIGXII...

Coug

2/21/18 11:47am

^^^^This

ABCoug

2/21/18 8:30pm

The miscalculation was the strength of MWC with BSU.

CosmoK

2/21/18 10:07am

Indy was absolutely the right move at the time. How it has shaken out can paint BYU in a bad light, but it's

Bob Vance

2/21/18 11:30am

I think this is what a lot of people ignore, BYU and the MWC did not get along

CougarVeteran

2/21/18 11:44am

And BYU paid the conference bills for years without receiving much benefit.

TailgateU

2/21/18 11:57am

Respectfully disagree. Indy was a knee jerk reaction to Utah joining P12.

ethanator

2/21/18 11:56am

BYU had just finished their broadcast facility

byukarl

2/21/18 12:10pm

Disagree. I hear that term used a lot, mostly by

rocker

2/21/18 1:26pm

I find the timing of the move interesting if it had pre-dated Utah's move

franklyvulgar

2/21/18 2:53pm

I don't think you guys are disagreeing with each other. I think rocker is just

Scratch

2/21/18 3:06pm

Agreed

franklyvulgar

2/21/18 3:18pm

Didnt BYU try to cut a deal with MWC like they tried with the WAC, football INDY

Coogar2

2/21/18 12:21pm

It sounds like they did, and the MWC balked at that (which is understandable).

Game Changer

2/21/18 1:07pm

We already knew Hair was a devil. This showed us Fresno and Nevada were too

Cougarclaw

2/21/18 12:45pm

I was really surprised we scheduled them as quickly as we did.

rocker

2/21/18 1:30pm

Me too

Hang10

2/21/18 2:00pm

I was NOT a fan.

Cougarclaw

2/21/18 2:22pm

Thanks for the research. This helps.

UofUCoug

2/21/18 4:45pm

interesting read. Amazing Hair has a job

byu1

2/21/18 5:38pm

One thing for sure, Utah left the MWC first. They started it

Coogar2

2/21/18 8:05pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad