one is a MUCH different scenario than a #112 finish after not finishing lower than 55 in over a decade.
If you HATED Bronco's 1st season, than you must also hate the last two seasons if you are being consistent.
The worst Bronco season was better than Kalani's average season. Kalani's best season was worse than Bronco's average season. Data don't lie. What stats am I cherry picking? You are the one dancing around the results. 2005-2015 BYU was much better than 2016-2018. Its not even a subjective thing — every objective fact backs this up wins, SOS, bowls, finishes, rival record, rankings, etc.
Kalani average finish (16-18) = 70
Bronco average finish (05-15) = 33