My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 14, 2019
6:08
:33
pm
puntersarepeople
Walk-on
Could end up with both
that would be a experience light group though with an FCS HC and FCS OC
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
puntersarepeople
Bio page
puntersarepeople
Joined
Jan 1, 2018
Last login
Jun 14, 2024
Total posts
33,611 (15 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
The more I learn about Jay Hill the more I like him as a candidate for next head coach
Odysseus
All-American
10/14/19 1:46pm
He should be the #1 Candidate
MikeDitka'sStache
10/14/19 1:47pm
I have him at #3 behind Bevell and Peterson. But great candidate.
Mrs Featerbottom
10/14/19 2:10pm
Why do you have Peterson above Jay Hill?
BYU Fan
10/14/19 2:13pm
Bevell, pipe dream. JH tops my list & ive never
MatthiasPhunkHausen
10/14/19 2:37pm
I agree it's unlikely (maybe zero chance), but I'd still ask him first.
Mrs Featerbottom
10/14/19 4:44pm
Couldn’t hurt
MatthiasPhunkHausen
10/14/19 6:21pm
I think it's a close choice. Three reasons I prefer Paul:
Mrs Featerbottom
10/14/19 3:14pm
I’ll have to do more research but he seems like a great choice
BYU Fan
10/14/19 3:27pm
He was on the radio making his case to be the OC after the 2017 season
CaliWG
10/14/19 3:33pm
Here's what I've found on Paul Peterson as an HC, with records, trends, & stats:
ldssdl
10/14/19 3:56pm
TL:DR Peterson is less proven than Hill, but has shown to be a good HC so far.
ldssdl
10/14/19 4:10pm
I’d go Peterson as well for the reasons you mentioned. Plus he’s currently 5-1
bigbossbyu
10/14/19 5:36pm
Agreed - I just think we need high energy + offensive minded.
Mrs Featerbottom
10/14/19 5:44pm
Could end up with both
puntersarepeople
10/14/19 6:08pm
I’m with you I think Peterson would be a great hire. So far he’s been a successful head coach at Snow and Dixie State
Nuke
10/14/19 8:29pm
When was he at Sac State? What did he coach and how did they do?
ldssdl
10/14/19 11:06pm
He was OC his whole tenure
Mrs Featerbottom
10/15/19 6:41am
Bevell has no recent college or HC experience. Why would he be on the list?
Benfica1
10/14/19 2:50pm
It’s sexy due to his stints in the NFL, and a small pool to choose from. It’s
pegushin
10/14/19 2:52pm
Detmer was a sexy pick as well.
Benfica1
10/14/19 3:08pm
Let's be honest, now...
Eddie
10/14/19 3:11pm
lol there was nothing sexy about that in any way
Lip Gallagher
10/14/19 4:16pm
Idk man, that drawl does it for people.
IceCreamButt
10/14/19 4:21pm
Because he's an NFL SB winning coordinator. Crowton comparisons are wrong
Mrs Featerbottom
10/14/19 3:18pm
I’m curious how well NFL coaches generally do
D.T. Survivor
10/14/19 5:34pm
And he still has no recent college football/recruiting experience. Who even
Benfica1
10/14/19 9:11pm
Don't disagree.
Mrs Featerbottom
10/15/19 6:42am
My one worry with him is who would be his assistants?
mudpupper
10/14/19 1:48pm
That is the biggest problem. These coaching staff are all unproven.
Cougar TD
10/14/19 1:50pm
That's sortof the problem with BYU
BrutustheBrash
10/14/19 1:52pm
Maybe Fesi? He was with him at Weber......
kansascougar
10/14/19 1:50pm
Not impressed with what the WRs have done under him.
crack
10/14/19 1:56pm
I think Hifo, Milne, and Romney have shown flashes.
ldssdl
10/14/19 1:59pm
Give him legit money to go coordinator shopping around the country
MikeDitka'sStache
10/14/19 1:51pm
IDK if that will happen though, that's the problem
BrutustheBrash
10/14/19 1:53pm
Ideally the best we could find
BYU Fan
10/14/19 1:54pm
IDK if people would like Ena
BrutustheBrash
10/14/19 1:56pm
"One last chance to succeed"? You serious?
Eddie
10/14/19 1:56pm
How irrelevant can BYU get before we reach a point of no return?
BYU Fan
10/14/19 1:58pm
How irrelevant was Weber State before Jay Hill took over?
Eddie
10/14/19 2:00pm
Apples and oranges
BYU Fan
10/14/19 2:03pm
It's probably a better example than you want to admit.
Eddie
10/14/19 2:13pm
Maybe so - it seems to be that BYU is headed in the wrong direction
BYU Fan
10/14/19 2:34pm
Fans are always anxious to come to a winner
BigBlue04
10/14/19 3:26pm
SMU is showing that *eventually* you can come back from complete burial.
squidmark
10/14/19 9:03pm
What about Jan Jorgenson? Supposedly he made a big difference at BYU as a GA.
ldssdl
10/14/19 2:00pm
<< Deleted >>
CrashMcLarson
10/14/19 2:16pm
I have confidence he wouldn’t go straight buddy route unless
MatthiasPhunkHausen
10/14/19 2:55pm
There's no requirement for assistants to be LDS. That should be much easier.
Ash
10/14/19 3:16pm
If he could bring in maybe Peterson at OC and Poppinga at DC, I think that would
Dynasty1
10/14/19 1:52pm
Certainly couldn't be worse than what we have now
MikeDitka'sStache
10/14/19 2:00pm
And if not Poppinga then Justin Ena as DC.
RdF3
10/14/19 2:03pm
I could jump on board that train.
mudpupper
10/14/19 2:05pm
Potential Rest of Offensive Staff:
MikeDitka'sStache
10/14/19 2:15pm
I like it but why would Jason Beck come back in a lateral move?
BYU Fan
10/14/19 2:17pm
Yeah, I don't see him coming back for anything less than OC
Dynasty1
10/14/19 2:26pm
give him the co-OC title, with a clear trajectory to promotion if he performs.
MikeDitka'sStache
10/14/19 2:27pm
Peterson will get better HC offers then Dixie soon. He’s turning the
bigbossbyu
10/14/19 5:39pm
Crazy young. Could be around for a LONG time
puntersarepeople
10/14/19 6:11pm
The trajectory looks great over 5.5 seasons, similar to Bronco's at UVA.
ldssdl
10/14/19 1:55pm
Wow I didn’t know all that. If we don’t fire Kalani and hire him now we might
JollyGreenGiant
10/14/19 1:57pm
Seems like a good option, but I'm nervous about how well FCS success translates
Jesse Pinkman
10/14/19 1:57pm
Honest question(s)
ldssdl
10/14/19 2:02pm
Fair points. Montana was a powerhouse in the 15 years before Glenn/Hauck
Jesse Pinkman
10/14/19 2:11pm
Isn't it all relative? It's still FCS vs FCS results, and it's about what
Lip Gallagher
10/14/19 2:04pm
Assuming he is a member? Saw he went to Ricks.
TPcoug
10/14/19 1:59pm
RM married in temple. Dad was seminary teacher.
Big Daddy D
10/14/19 2:00pm
Insanity
wbcougster
10/14/19 2:00pm
Maybe we should baptize Charlie Strong and he could be our next HC?
StarMan
10/14/19 2:00pm
I agree. I'd be fine with Hill, Anderson or Anae.
CaliWG
10/14/19 2:01pm
I think Beck will eventually become a BYU HC. Id love him as OC under Hill.
MikeDitka'sStache
10/14/19 2:02pm
Besides being a student of the game, what makes us think Beck would be any better than Grimes?
Bob Vance
10/14/19 2:07pm
Beck needs to get his feet wet first unless he comes under an offensive HC.
Lip Gallagher
10/14/19 2:09pm
Anyone but Dr. Bob. Even Kenny Niumatlulolo and the wishbone over Bob.
TPcoug
10/14/19 2:02pm
Anae is better than what we currently have.
Cougar TD
10/14/19 2:07pm
We know his coaching philosophy & that his system works at BYU
CaliWG
10/14/19 2:08pm
Those names are all over the place. It would depend on the combo.
Lip Gallagher
10/14/19 2:08pm
Anderson with Poppinga would be a solid fit
CaliWG
10/14/19 2:13pm
Eh, still not interested in him as a HC.
Lip Gallagher
10/14/19 2:37pm
I'm not really impressed with their offenses outside of Fesi's.
Lip Gallagher
10/14/19 2:04pm
What are the stats of Weber's offenses before, during, and after Fesi?
ldssdl
10/14/19 2:06pm
Fesi was Weber State's OC 2016-17
Odysseus
10/14/19 2:14pm
Deleted
RockyBalboa
10/14/19 2:18pm
RE: What are the stats of Weber's offenses before, during, and after Fesi?
Lip Gallagher
10/14/19 2:31pm
They’ve played two FBS teams so far which skews this year’s stats a bit. No doubt Jay would need a solid OC though
Odysseus
10/14/19 2:37pm
It's FCS. They're all playing FBS schools at some point. And many of them
Lip Gallagher
10/14/19 2:47pm
He also wont take a kid if gpa is less than 2.75 in core classes
CarolinaCoug
10/14/19 2:08pm
When Jay Hill goes the FBS route it won't be to BYU
RockyBalboa
10/14/19 2:19pm
That's what I've heard as well.
Eddie
10/14/19 2:22pm
Me too. Weber State is his DREAM job
cougarnw
10/14/19 3:07pm
Do you know him personally or something? It seems like it would be a no brainer
Dynasty1
10/14/19 2:23pm
People who do know him personally and who have asked him about BYU...
Eddie
10/14/19 2:29pm
Unless taking the BYU job puts him at a severe disadvantage going forward
BYU Fan
10/14/19 2:29pm
In all fairness - we're talking about an EXTREMELY small sample size.
Eddie
10/14/19 2:32pm
That's not really true. LaVell has as big of a coaching tree as anybody in NCAA
Dynasty1
10/14/19 2:32pm
Eh...people don't take the HC job at BYU to turn it into an OC job elsewhere.
Eddie
10/14/19 2:37pm
True but that happens all of the time. An example, Sarkisian squandered his HC
Dynasty1
10/14/19 2:41pm
Probably what killed his opportunity top be a HC elsewhere was the rape scandal
goobermcmonkey
10/14/19 3:26pm
Let's look at recent history - yes Lavell had some great coaches but this isn't
BYU Fan
10/14/19 2:42pm
AMEN!!!
Palestra
10/14/19 8:30pm
Or if he could get BYU to 8-9 wins every year, he has his pick at aP5 opening.
cougaman
10/14/19 2:26pm
He may have that soon anyway without going to BYU
BYU Fan
10/14/19 2:30pm
No FCS HC is going to "have their pick" of P5 programs.
Resurgens
10/14/19 8:06pm
Similar things were said about Notre Dame for years
CaliWG
10/14/19 2:29pm
ND suddenly got better when they pseudo-joined the ACC.
BrobaFett
10/14/19 10:48pm
FBS jobs are hard to come by. He's not turning anyone down from BYU who comes offering.
Turnpike Lane
10/14/19 2:35pm
<< Deleted >>
Gustav
10/14/19 2:50pm
Didn't the guy who made NDSU an FCS powerhouse get his big FBS break at mighty
Resurgens
10/14/19 8:08pm
Then he should be aware of the advantages as well
Jericho
10/14/19 2:39pm
At this point, other than compensation, do the advantages outweigh the
shakarocks
10/14/19 2:47pm
Disagree. We have as many or more advantages as disadvantages
Jericho
10/14/19 2:57pm
Yeah, he's in such demand right now. He'd turn down 1 of 130 possible jobs.
Benfica1
10/14/19 2:51pm
Easy for him to say now.
Carnac
10/14/19 2:58pm
How many FBS offers has he turned down?
cougarnw
10/14/19 3:09pm
They’re ranked #5 nationally FCS too, great D, &
MatthiasPhunkHausen
10/14/19 2:35pm
The only issue is how many times “FCS” and not “FBS” is used
kscores2
10/14/19 3:58pm
Jay Hill will listen...
Vernon Dozier
10/14/19 4:14pm
So he's gonna pass on BYU so he can go coach New Mexico?
CaliWG
10/14/19 4:34pm
Doubt UNM.. but Nevada or CSU?
Vernon Dozier
10/14/19 5:42pm
It depends on if it's easier to get noticed by a P5 program there.
displacedute
10/14/19 5:43pm
Also Jay Hill’s dream job is Utah...
Vernon Dozier
10/14/19 5:46pm
Agreed, he's third in line there.
Mrs Featerbottom
10/14/19 6:58pm
I bet the behind the scenes fight for Utah when KW retires is going to be big.
BleedCougarBlue2
10/14/19 7:09pm
Just out of curiosity -
Eddie
10/15/19 1:09am
If that’s the case I hope he’s honest and wish him the best.
Dr MoBYU
10/14/19 8:20pm
Pretty convincing.
Dr MoBYU
10/14/19 5:43pm
Yup, thought the same think when I looked up his record and posted about it.....
BleedCougarBlue2
10/14/19 6:57pm
RE: The more I learn about Jay Hill the more I like him as a candidate for next
Blewballs
10/14/19 11:28pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad