with divine inspiration, then we should never trust a subjective process. I'm fine with seminary graduation and eclesiastical endorsement being number 1 and number 2 on the list. Those can both be "check-the-box" items. After that, ACT should be number 3 followed by GPA and other factors such as number of AP classes, extracurriculars, etc. and even geography, background, etc.
It should NEVER come down to the BYU admissions office reviewing 60,000 essays or seminary teacher recommendations.