That's it! The Branbury. One of the greatest news articles I've ever read.

Report problem with this ad

Oct 7, 2015
10:23:26am

RealComfortableJeans

Report problem with this ad

RealComfortableJeans

Previous username: Chad Bunn
Bio page: RealComfortableJeans
Joined: Dec 3, 2009
Last login: Jun 16, 2024
Total posts: 12,395 (573 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

"I was one semester away from graduation, left the church, & was expelled"

snowbird

10/7/15 10:10am

The trays do come back full at the Belmont.

RealComfortableJeans

10/7/15 10:14am

lol, used to be Branbury Park in the late 80's early 90's.

boogers

10/7/15 10:19am

That's it! The Branbury. One of the greatest news articles I've ever read.

RealComfortableJeans

10/7/15 10:23am

I tend to agree

Northwest Cougar

10/7/15 10:15am

Honestly, if it's your last semester, you won't need another ecclesiastical

dilbert

10/7/15 10:21am

We make choices. They have consequences. When has that ever changed?

HangookCoug

10/7/15 10:39am

Still have to go to church because your Bishop can pull your ecclesiastical at

sandtrapcougar

10/7/15 10:54am

I have never met a person first hand that this has happened to.

andrewth

10/7/15 11:09am

How many people have you met that just stopped going to church while at BYU?

sandtrapcougar

10/7/15 1:09pm

Would they even be guaranteed to notice?

Northwest Cougar

10/7/15 1:42pm

Well part of the Honor Code is that you attend your BYU ward regularly.

sandtrapcougar

10/7/15 1:49pm

At BYU wards people are moving in and out so often it's impossible to keep track

andrewth

10/7/15 4:17pm

BYU wards have very little turnover during the semester. So it is actually easy

sandtrapcougar

10/7/15 4:20pm

I'm curious how you track attendance in your YSA ward

dilbert

10/7/15 4:40pm

I have a feeling the Demographic of your YSA Ward is very different than mine.

andrewth

10/7/15 4:57pm

Start with the rolls in each class. Then each month we compile list of

sandtrapcougar

10/7/15 9:58pm

Ah, ok. I was thinking more about sacrament meeting, but that makes sense.

dilbert

10/7/15 10:11pm

I had 4 close friends going into BYU. 3 of the 4 Flat out stopped going.

andrewth

10/7/15 4:13pm

Agreed

HangookCoug

10/7/15 10:17am

Ummm. Non-LDS people go to BYU all the time. Also, ND is full of non-catholics

srey

10/7/15 10:40am

This is utter nonsense.

Singcat

10/7/15 11:18am

People are risk adverse by nature; saving your butt far outweighs "being

kunarcougar

10/7/15 10:21am

I'm torn on this issue . . .

Gavin

10/7/15 10:25am

Because they were admitted based on academic and religious

CMM Cougar

10/7/15 11:37am

THIS ^^^^^^

Monomachos

10/7/15 12:47pm

i guess what you are saying is you don't want anyone at BYU who struggles with

run26

10/7/15 1:10pm

See, that's the way the policy is perceived

Gavin

10/7/15 2:19pm

Did you read what the BYU spokesperson actually said? There is a difference

Monomachos

10/7/15 2:45pm

even if you've "made up your mind" you might come back

run26

10/7/15 4:06pm

IMO, it doesn't really matter what the intent of the person is.

blackandblue

10/7/15 10:31am

Here's my thing. Every year, I am charged with finding 70-75 HS students whose

Six Foot Seven

10/7/15 10:38am

Boom.

Iman23

10/7/15 10:39am

Pretty sure they aren't asking to keep the subsidized tuition. Pay the non LDS

Mr. Scoobs

10/7/15 10:54am

Non LDS students get huge subsidies as well.

boogers

10/7/15 10:58am

The cost to the church is still very much there. They continue to fund every

Six Foot Seven

10/7/15 11:00am

So why the inconsistent treatment between them and other non-LDS kids?

swingcat

10/7/15 11:06am

I understand what yo are saying, but it isn't the same. By choosing to

boogers

10/7/15 11:23am

But isn't ever non-member kind of "rejecting" it too?

jayriggity

10/7/15 11:28am

I think you get the point. Pro-actively disassociating from the Church

boogers

10/7/15 11:49am

Yep. The difference had to do with making a covenant and then breaking it

dilbert

10/7/15 12:57pm

There isn't an inconsistency.

Six Foot Seven

10/7/15 11:29am

??? That's totally inconsistent.

jayriggity

10/7/15 11:37am

No, I'm sorry, but you are wrong.

Six Foot Seven

10/7/15 11:38am

Hmm. I guess we'll have to agree to disagree about that. Seems quite private to

jayriggity

10/7/15 11:54am

...and? Who cares how many people know about it? You can still do it in a

Byron McNertney

10/7/15 11:56am

And I don't disagree with any of that. This discussion was about what gives BYU

Six Foot Seven

10/7/15 12:14pm

BYU has the "right" to whatever it wants (IMO). But as an institution of integri

jayriggity

10/7/15 12:36pm

Okay, let me try again.

Six Foot Seven

10/7/15 12:52pm

Thats an interesting way to look at it. And this is an honest question: does the

jayriggity

10/7/15 1:03pm

I doubt there would be repercussions for a nonmember in your example because,

Six Foot Seven

10/7/15 1:14pm

I would imagine the same rules would apply. Let me explain:

lawilson

10/7/15 1:19pm

so an LDS student who went inactive could get endorsed by another religion's

run26

10/7/15 1:25pm

No... because that person is still a member of the church.

lawilson

10/7/15 1:35pm

According to the organization making a fuss about this, BYU really doesn't look

jayriggity

10/7/15 2:09pm

However I will propose an interesting thought:

lawilson

10/7/15 1:47pm

Who do I get my ecclesiastical endorsement from if I have removed my name

lawilson

10/7/15 11:20am

There are plenty of non-LDS that still get endorsments from chaplains. Don't

Mr. Scoobs

10/7/15 11:22am

You misunderstand.... If they can get an ecclesiastical endorsement

lawilson

10/7/15 11:42am

Right. They would still need to live the honor code and would get endorsed by a

Mr. Scoobs

10/7/15 11:48am

One of my brother's good friends actually WAS one semester away from graduating

LeftOfNormal

10/7/15 10:39am

Why are they idiots? Because they don't agree with Mormon doctrine? You do

Singcat

10/7/15 11:21am

No, they are idiots because of how they chose to behave. But they certainly

boogers

10/7/15 11:25am

But that behavior is only idiotic to you because you don't agree with it or what

Singcat

10/7/15 11:30am

I have plenty of personal issues that I struggle with that are contrary to what

boogers

10/7/15 11:38am

I'm pretty confident this whole incident was planned in advance to embarrass BYU

BeardedSpock

10/7/15 1:03pm

What it really boils down to is admission to BYU is a contract: for the

Monomachos

10/7/15 11:27pm

I actually only knew one person who started LDS at BYU, stopped going to church,

Ygirl

10/8/15 9:39am

It is possible to transfer credits and finish a degree elsewhere. Was

Monomachos

10/8/15 9:57am

I'm not sure. BYU looks very good on a resume though.

Ygirl

10/8/15 12:11pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad