My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Apr 19, 2017
7:32
:45
am
roseyscenario
All-American
This is the truth.
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Apr 19, 2017 at 7:32:45am
Message modified by roseyscenario on Apr 19, 2017 at 7:33:21am
Message modified by roseyscenario on Apr 19, 2017 at 7:34:32am
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
roseyscenario
Previous username
addedupon
Bio page
roseyscenario
Joined
Jul 15, 2011
Last login
Sep 20, 2024
Total posts
24,171 (4,123 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Beo response to the Harmon article.
Dishonor Code
4/18/17 3:18pm
Expected more? BYU did of him too. Also, His schollie was a 1=year commitment, so BYU met it.
Turnpike Lane
4/18/17 3:20pm
I disagree that "there is nothing wrong with it".
Lance71
4/18/17 3:24pm
I disagree that there is "nothing wrong with it." It is common, but common
reagan21
4/18/17 3:24pm
HACK!
reagan21
4/18/17 3:24pm
So there is no accountability on the player for his performance?
jigidajrit
4/18/17 3:26pm
That's quite the logic leap from "nothing wrong with it". It's not all or nothin
Lance71
4/18/17 3:29pm
That's fair. Just noticed that you two were disagreeing with
jigidajrit
4/18/17 3:30pm
Some schools are moving to the 4 year guaranteed scholorship i.e. USC
DK-
4/18/17 3:29pm
Sure wish someone would give me money so that I could claim it was my investment
CougarThug
4/19/17 11:08am
Do you think that accurately depicts Beo? No way. By your standard
reagan21
4/18/17 3:30pm
I wish there were more scholarships available
jigidajrit
4/18/17 3:35pm
NOMINATED!!
CarolinaCoug
4/18/17 4:21pm
The power conferences no longer pull scholarships for performance issues.
Everyman
4/18/17 3:37pm
Or, he can stay in school and pay his own way to graduate like 98% of the rest of the student body,
Turnpike Lane
4/18/17 3:31pm
No. It sucks. There is something wrong with it, and it shows freshmen
reagan21
4/18/17 3:34pm
It is a 1-year offer. He got his 1 year. THe next was not renewed per the contract.
Turnpike Lane
4/18/17 3:38pm
We don't really know that's the case.
Lance71
4/18/17 3:39pm
What in that statement is unknown?
dratax
4/19/17 10:53am
We don't know if he is being offered to stay on the team as a walk on.
Lance71
4/19/17 10:56am
Yes, and BYU has limited his options by pulling a scholarship in April.
reagan21
4/18/17 3:43pm
You do realize April is when this happens for hoops right? After the season is over.
Turnpike Lane
4/18/17 3:48pm
you do realize that AAU coaches will pawn lower level kids on coaches for
reagan21
4/18/17 3:57pm
So because UNLV kept that kid even through a string of run ins with the law, it means BYU
RoaroftheCougartails
4/18/17 5:13pm
Probably. It's part of the recruiting game.
reagan21
4/19/17 10:29am
RE: Yes, and BYU has limited his options by pulling a scholarship in April.
Bullrider
4/20/17 11:44am
This isnt football
Shteve
4/18/17 3:47pm
Doesn't have to be. It is that way for all NCAA sports. Unless the school offers says 4-years. Most are 1 year.
Turnpike Lane
4/18/17 3:51pm
Referring to FCS, not scholarships. Yes, all scholarships are 1 yr.
Shteve
4/18/17 3:57pm
What a load.
Prickly Heat
4/20/17 8:33am
What if the athlete was not offered a scholarship and came as a walk on. Due to circumstances
RoaroftheCougartails
4/18/17 5:11pm
What do school do with Academic Scholarships that do not
pappabear246
4/19/17 8:29am
Or the school simply runs out of scholarships. The line has to be drawn some place.
soupie
4/19/17 8:36am
My family has had basketball scholorships from two different schools
DK-
4/18/17 3:26pm
Bull crap. Chasing away freshmen is just stupid
GeauxCougs
4/18/17 3:31pm
Part of the game, but how this part of it happens varies
Gustav
4/18/17 3:48pm
Like they said, "there's a lot more to" it. Maybe it wasn't all about the
mantis mutu
4/18/17 3:56pm
we yearned for more of his ball handling? you realize one of his only games
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 4:28pm
That was a bad NIT performance, but his stats don't tell the full story.
mantis mutu
4/18/17 4:39pm
hard to say since his only meaningful stretch of minutes on the season came
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 5:11pm
I disagree that BYU expected more of him
teancum
4/18/17 4:13pm
BYU expected more out of a freshman? I really doubt that.
Lip Gallagher
4/18/17 6:04pm
Turnpike Lane is absolutely spot on here. Not sure why people can't get that.
RdF3
4/19/17 8:06am
Tell them we will miss him and wish him the best
byusc23
4/18/17 3:21pm
Personally I would have kept him on scholarship (if that was the issue). He
Dangerous
4/18/17 3:21pm
Depends on the scholarship situation. He came as a walk-on. Thought he was used way more than expected.
soupie
4/18/17 3:24pm
Is it just me, or does it seem like this type of thing is happening more than
inertiaman
4/18/17 3:21pm
No. Signs of a division 1 basketball team. It's not just happening at BYU.
reagan21
4/18/17 3:22pm
More than usual for BYU recently, but in normal amounts for most programs.
Turnpike Lane
4/18/17 3:22pm
I don't think it's a normal amount for successful programs. I'm not advocating
gwalker
4/18/17 3:34pm
It happens at the big programs quite a bit, they often pull in
califcougar
4/18/17 3:51pm
Doesn't the linked article track 10 guys over a 15 year period? We're hitting a
gwalker
4/18/17 3:59pm
How many of the guys are leaving because they don't want to be part of the
califcougar
4/18/17 4:48pm
Not so sure about the last 3 on your list. Pretty sure Toolson & Guinn would have been welcomed back. No idea
soupie
4/18/17 4:59pm
Sidnt we lose a disgruntled player to Ok st? Pretty sure FB 3 was digruntled too
CarolinaCoug
4/19/17 12:55pm
Yup
teancum
4/18/17 4:09pm
Asked to step aside for another scholarship? Bad for Beo family, but it's just
reagan21
4/18/17 3:21pm
It's really tough when you were really a preferred walk-on all along
Indy Coug
4/18/17 3:23pm
That's a pretty big departure from this
donnerstag
4/18/17 3:24pm
Thanks for sharing. Please tell Sister Beo and Cougar Nation wishes her son the
BIG XII Coug
4/18/17 3:25pm
All of these really hurt, especially this one. I thought Beo showed real promise
LegitCoug
4/18/17 3:25pm
I thought he'd be a nice role player for years to come
donnerstag
4/18/17 3:27pm
He was a level-headed player who didn't make many mistakes.
Freddie Cougar
4/18/17 3:32pm
The sad thing is that it's only a business for the school not for the kids
thebruce
4/18/17 3:29pm
Not only is this common for D1 sports ... it's common for schollies PERIOD.
runnincoug
4/18/17 3:30pm
The tough thing here is that we will probably never see the other side of the story.
TheWanderer
4/18/17 3:31pm
He should still be on the roster even if he's not on scholarship. I don't have
ayfan
4/18/17 3:32pm
my bet, he was offered to go back to walk-on status and felt slighted by that.
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 3:37pm
Tell him he will be treated like family at SUU
GeauxCougs
4/18/17 3:32pm
Was he given the chance to play as a walk-on next year?
Greg Kite's 'stache
4/18/17 3:33pm
We lose LJ Rose. If Aytes and Kaufusi are gone, I don't see why
gwalker
4/18/17 3:33pm
Kaufusi is a football schollie, not hoops, per NCAA rules.
Turnpike Lane
4/18/17 3:35pm
True. Switch in Davis leaving too and you get to the same place in terms of
gwalker
4/18/17 3:36pm
Corbin was already counted as FB this last season so he's out of the mix anyway.
soupie
4/18/17 3:40pm
Rumor i heard IN February said beo might be leaving. I doubt rose is asking
BYUheaven
4/18/17 3:34pm
Interesting. Beo was a frosh and played like it. Small, not quick
Coogar2
4/18/17 9:13pm
hard to complain that you were promised a pref. walk-on spot and got a
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 3:35pm
What did he do that showed anything worth the scholarship?
IronPotato
4/18/17 3:44pm
This is distressing. Too much of this has been occurring
dixdog
4/18/17 3:51pm
Work on those dribbling and passing skills
dizthewiz
4/18/17 4:07pm
I don't necessarily think airing the grievance publicly is the right way to
Iman23
4/18/17 4:09pm
George Costanza probably agrees.
Shteve
4/18/17 4:20pm
you mean Frank?
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 4:32pm
lol no, Frank would disagree.
Shteve
4/18/17 4:41pm
true
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 4:51pm
Who is airing grievances?
Remigius
4/18/17 4:37pm
Beo's mom asked this to be posted. I'd say Beo camp is airing grievances...
Iman23
4/18/17 4:48pm
This is your evidence of grievance:
Mises
4/18/17 4:54pm
That was not the intent. The original post has been edited.
Dishonor Code
4/18/17 4:57pm
Didn't seem to be airing grievance. Seemed pretty classy to me. Didn't throw an
Big Daddy D
4/18/17 4:59pm
original message was edited, you didn't see the whole thing
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 5:13pm
Oh, yes, I never saw the original. Late to the party, as usual.
Big Daddy D
4/18/17 5:19pm
gotta quit that job and surf CB constantly all day long.
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 5:23pm
No doubt. I would be so much more in the know living out of my car!
Big Daddy D
4/18/17 7:57pm
The second part of the message was deleted.
BerkeleyCoug
4/18/17 5:14pm
This is the truth.
roseyscenario
4/19/17 7:32am
Why is it Beo's fault that Emery plays poorly?
CarolinaCoug
4/18/17 4:20pm
What on earth does Emery have to do with this?
Freddie Cougar
4/18/17 4:52pm
<< Deleted >>
Abe Froman
4/20/17 8:21am
Based on her text it sounds like he's leaving this world.
Thug Mormons
4/18/17 4:33pm
I literally LOL d
DumpsterFire
4/18/17 11:41pm
why did you delete the second part of her text?
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 4:34pm
THIS WHOLE THREAD SHOULD NOW BE DELETED
Shteve
4/18/17 5:29pm
why? no one has personally attacked Beo or the coaching staff
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 5:38pm
Maybe Rose can't coach players up and so getting rid of someone who needs a bit
84 Grad
4/18/17 5:15pm
he did "coach up" a National Player of the Year from a barely recruited
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 5:29pm
I miss Dave Rice. BYU basketball hasn't been the same since he left.
84 Grad
4/18/17 5:40pm
what did he do specifically to coach them up?
icecougar
4/18/17 6:43pm
lol, so he gets 0 credit for the successes but all the blame for the failures?
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 6:55pm
No, the credit he gets is different. Not for developing him but recognizing...
icecougar
4/20/17 12:33am
Jimmer perfectly fit Rose's ad lib, free-flowing shoot at will
unctoothman
4/18/17 7:09pm
Rose's system absolutely made Jimmer. If Jimmer hadn't had the massive
LEHI cougar
4/18/17 7:15pm
So your definition of Coaching Up is Do What You Want?
84 Grad
4/18/17 7:19pm
You can't be that obtuse? Jimmer didn't get better from his
LEHI cougar
4/19/17 7:33am
Your words: "Massive green light and 0 accountability."
84 Grad
4/19/17 7:56am
BINGO!
icecougar
4/20/17 12:34am
tell them we're sad to see him leave
icecougar
4/18/17 6:39pm
My take? This blows.
byujdmba
4/18/17 10:19pm
I don't think he was ever going to be a star, but I don't think that matters
Epileptic Beagle
4/18/17 11:27pm
May sound harsh but you can get a million kids like him anytime. He's probably a good kid but in all
The Dude Abides
4/18/17 11:46pm
Sure but there is value in retention and not having to retrain everyone every
Epileptic Beagle
4/19/17 12:08am
I definitely see your point and with guys like Chatman, Bartley, Neilson, etc I 100% agree. I just don't think
The Dude Abides
4/19/17 8:01am
Totally agree. Great kid, maybe a hard worker, not really a D1 player. Definitely not worth a scholarship
RoaroftheCougartails
4/19/17 9:07am
While I doubt he'd ever be a starter
donnerstag
4/19/17 9:19am
It's Even more sad than when Joanie Loves Chachi was cancelled.
Belboz
4/18/17 11:45pm
Maybe he'll start lobbing law bombs or start a law blog
mcnasty
4/20/17 11:21am
RE: Beo response to the Harmon article.
visitor
4/19/17 12:57pm
Sad that we have totally put our eggs into the LP3.
Blue for Life
4/19/17 6:16pm
It's the reality of college basketball right now. Unless you are a perrenial top
Lance71
4/19/17 6:24pm
I think Steven is a Great kid! Would have loved for him to stay. Agree with some of what you said.
RoaroftheCougartails
4/19/17 6:44pm
Was aware of some of this but not all. Personally I was hoping he would stay and develop. Thought he did well
soupie
4/19/17 8:28pm
I agree. It's poor form and bad karma to
bigjohn
4/20/17 7:33am
Not sure you got out of my message what I meant, but okay.
soupie
4/20/17 8:35am
I got your message and agree. Juggling scholarships is not easy in basketball
LV Mike
4/20/17 9:06am
Exactly. I'm more concerned about "how" things are handled than the actual actions. Those
soupie
4/20/17 9:50am
Frankly this was my take, too
byujdmba
4/19/17 10:58pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad