Defintely? Maybe sure sefinitelt iseasy to debate.

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 23, 2017
3:36:46pm

CarolinaCoug All-American

Defintely? Maybe sure sefinitelt iseasy to debate.

In 15 he ad a Sr rb Hine and was 3 plays away from being 1-5 to start have Hine and the next 3 rb's gobdo2n and mangum and csre go down after thill and then what do you think his final record is? Maybe 3 and 9, 4 and 8. That was with experienced wr's .this team has no go to wr except a true freshman te.

So 6 wins with this team wold b3 unlikely vs this schedule this year. Keep in mond,BMS great defenses struggle vs any passing team in the top 40's..so this defense which would not be great under BM rither, would have got kit up by teams that can pass like always.

Report problem with this ad

CarolinaCoug

Bio page: CarolinaCoug
Joined: Dec 9, 2002
Last login: Apr 28, 2024
Total posts: 60,419 (3,190 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

We need a coach that can establish and define a culture. Bronco’s stern affect

Run-DMT

11/21/17 1:07am

Everything Bronco was mocked for is everything we are missing. Most of us have

Cougarfan777

11/21/17 1:20am

I was told Sitake’s “culture” was what we were missing before. Which was

DirtyWater

11/21/17 7:37am

Those weren’t the things that irritated fans

antiyewt

11/21/17 9:06am

Yep. Also recruiting blunders and we plateaued at 8 wins per season for 4 yrs

D.T. Survivor

11/21/17 9:13am

I would die for 8 wins this year. Or 7 or even 6.

OmahaThunderCoug

11/21/17 9:28am

I would love that too. Some of us (me for sure) took 8 wins for granted.

D.T. Survivor

11/21/17 9:33am

You would? Really? If it was the 7th season in a row of 8 wins you'd

SandYFan

11/21/17 9:41am

Forgot to mention recruiting

antiyewt

11/21/17 9:38am

Would love to see evidence that Kalani

kooogar

11/21/17 10:03am

Come on, there were a bunch of high profile transfers

antiyewt

11/21/17 10:10am

Between dads being hired as coaches and Kalani's initial popularity,

kooogar

11/21/17 1:51pm

Okay, let's look at those complaints and I'll point out where Bronco used

Cougarfan777

11/21/17 11:18am

Hurray for Bronco! He’s just so dreamy!

Paul Hewson

11/21/17 7:47pm

8-5 8-5 8-5 losses to Utah, Moo U, bsu

Paul Hewson

11/21/17 7:45pm

Great post. And i agree.....every b should see this now. It’s been obvious for

OmahaThunderCoug

11/21/17 9:26am

WRONG, 100% WRONG. Runs up to the Y and those other things are NOT

Kerbouchard

11/21/17 11:49am

slogans, firesides . . . don't lie to yourself.

11/21/17 2:13pm

Bronco was a negative Nancy and hated fans. That never changed. He resented

LV Mike

11/21/17 9:43pm

As long as you don't include recruiting and a few other things

youngbuck

11/22/17 4:59pm

Agree that this is the foundation that's missing. Can Kalani change his ways to

ManinChina

11/21/17 1:38am

That’s a great question. Sometimes it’s hard to predict who can set culture

Run-DMT

11/21/17 1:44am

Some may not like it but Dr. ANAE

kahuna

11/21/17 2:13am

Yes, and he’d be more qualified than at least 90%

Run-DMT

11/21/17 2:31am

Similar reasons to why Chow should have got the job after LaVell, but some

Polecat

11/21/17 8:38am

Chow?! Yeah, he did such a great job at Hawaii as HC, right?

Kerbouchard

11/21/17 11:52am

Give me a break. BYU in 2001 is not similar at all to Hawaii a few years ago

Polecat

11/21/17 11:58am

Kalani doesn’t have the organizational skills to do it...unless he learns from Bronco’s reading list

Bonoman

11/21/17 7:25am

It takes more than books you either have it or you Don't for the most part could

kahuna

11/21/17 9:59am

If you were to pin me down...I would say Kalani doesn't have it...

Bonoman

11/21/17 10:42am

Corporate cliches and buzz words are what clueless people use because they think

Paul Hewson

11/21/17 7:49pm

You seem to have a good read on reality, love your 6 thumbs down to 1 up!

kooogar

11/21/17 11:03pm

The more thumbs down the better on CB. You people are freaks.

Paul Hewson

11/21/17 11:25pm

Bronco’s “outstanding seasons” all happened in the MWC.

mm73

11/21/17 4:54am

Right but he never even came close to 3 and 10

Soy Celeste

11/21/17 5:02am

many of our losses were to non P5 schools we should beat.

GA_Coug

11/21/17 6:07am

define many

MormonThug

11/21/17 11:16am

Even his bad seasons were a trillion times more enjoyable than this one.

ballen

11/21/17 6:15am

I vehemently diaagree..maybe a billion,million,actually maybe onklly 2×

11/22/17 11:29am

They also happened to be the years when he had healthy QBs.

11/21/17 7:05am

Its funny how all of those healthy QBs played in the same offense

CaliWG

11/21/17 8:52am

And before he ditched Anae the first time

CaliWG

11/21/17 8:51am

Bronco was mocked for running it like a business. I never understood why.

SlantRoute

11/21/17 7:01am

He got mocked because that always gave the impression he was running a business,

Polecat

11/21/17 8:14am

Still, Bronco’s approach would’ve yielded 6-7 wins at least this season.

SlantRoute

11/21/17 10:45am

Definitely. I was just stating why it bothered people, myself included.

Polecat

11/21/17 2:29pm

Defintely? Maybe sure sefinitelt iseasy to debate.

11/23/17 3:36pm

That's what Bronco did, and Sitake seemed to miss on.

Eddie

11/21/17 9:18am

Agreed. Even though I can’t stand you. May see you at Christmas. Not sure yet

OmahaThunderCoug

11/21/17 9:30am

Completely agree. However, I will say it was time for a change—for both

BYUHgrad

11/21/17 7:04am

I think that’s fair Change was needed, and we made the wrong change.

SlantRoute

11/21/17 7:08am

It might not even be the budget as much as it's the restrictions that

kotacoug

11/21/17 7:11am

It sure seems like Holliday really wanted to be here, but either the money

11/21/17 7:19am

I would say the resources are more of the problem than what you are describing.

BYUHgrad

11/21/17 7:20am

Btw, has Steve Young weighed in on the issues lately? He’s a guru of team

Run-DMT

11/21/17 7:45am

Here's what he said in September after our 27-0 loss to LSU, and it wasn't good:

Brisco

11/21/17 8:12am

A Guru?

SlantRoute

11/21/17 8:47am

He would make a very good consultant to the AD and HC sharing some...

icecougar

11/21/17 10:38am

Would make a very good AD

Big Daddy D

11/21/17 2:54pm

That was my first thought but I could never see him wanting to be tied down...

icecougar

11/21/17 8:01pm

Totally agree that we need a cultural identity, but ...

blue13

11/21/17 9:16am

Clearly a lack of leadership.

Soy Celeste

11/21/17 9:29am

This is right in line with Sun Tzu's "The Art of War"

ChurroNieves

11/21/17 9:36am

Are you suggesting the team “needs a little motivation”?

BYUHgrad

11/21/17 10:26am

the latter half of Bronco's tenure BYU became a very undisciplined...

icecougar

11/21/17 10:34am

Bronco didn’t care about penalties

antiyewt

11/21/17 10:52am

or nut punches, late hits, brawls, etc

icecougar

11/21/17 8:05pm

This board is mostly about opinions, and I disagree with every single one of

kooogar

11/21/17 2:34pm

yes, it's about opinions and you put forth a lot of them...

icecougar

11/21/17 9:25pm

I appreciate the response, I was disappointed with the brawl and several

kooogar

11/21/17 10:47pm

There's no myth about Crowton's recruiting...

icecougar

11/22/17 3:51pm

This post needs more attention!!!! Awesome analysis sir.

11/22/17 6:25pm

<< Deleted >>

kooogar

11/22/17 11:19pm

Yes, Bronco won with Crowton's players, the point being discussed was the myth

kooogar

11/22/17 11:10pm

Forget the star rankings and look at what the players did over their careers...

icecougar

11/23/17 4:58am

OK, Bronco took Crowton's 60th rated classes and averaged 26th ranked finishes

kooogar

11/23/17 8:31am

RE: Yes, Bronco won with Crowton's players, the point being discussed was the

icecougar

11/23/17 5:48am

What do you think BYU's record would be if Bronco hadn't left? Assume

Soy Celeste

11/23/17 6:43am

Last year's success (also 4 games where they won in OT or on a last second

kooogar

11/23/17 8:38am

I agree with cultural carryover. It's now been replaced with hakuna matata.

Soy Celeste

11/23/17 9:43am

We need a coach that can establish and define a culture. Really?

socorny

11/21/17 10:51am

How many years did it take for Bronco to field a decent team after the Crowton debacle?

Brisco

11/21/17 10:56am

Um, the W-L record is a really good indicator

antiyewt

11/21/17 10:56am

There are plenty of other factors affecting the W-L record.

socorny

11/21/17 11:10am

The first red flag came for me during fall camp. I remember hearing players talk

Soy Celeste

11/21/17 2:32pm

That was worrisome for me too

antiyewt

11/21/17 2:44pm

Have you ever had responsibility for a large organization? Certainly

Soy Celeste

11/21/17 11:00am

We must not be listening to the same media outlets.

canofpicante

11/21/17 12:09pm

We need Captain Moroni more than ever!

Paul Hewson

11/21/17 7:43pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad