My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 9, 2022
6:16
:20
am
ryebrye
All-American
I think the part you're missing is he is not helping himself out AT ALL
how much notice do you think his next employee is going to give him?
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
ryebrye
Bio page
ryebrye
Joined
Dec 13, 2015
Last login
Oct 31, 2024
Total posts
9,429 (4 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
I just let an employee go today for only giving me a one week notice
Sale
8/8/22 10:35pm
Happens all the time. When two weeks notice comes in, employees are told not to come back. If they're going to competit
Dark Forest Green
8/8/22 10:37pm
The Navy made me give 8 months notice
BYU Tar Heel
8/9/22 12:16pm
Seems petty but whatever
BIG XII Coug
8/8/22 10:37pm
So, you think employees giving a one week notice is acceptable?
Sale
8/8/22 10:40pm
and actually in this case, only a 4 day notice
Sale
8/8/22 10:41pm
M-F is 5 days
ochobeeguy
8/8/22 10:54pm
well, technically 4.5, but ok
Sale
8/8/22 10:57pm
One issue it may cause it employees will not give any notice after securing a
Thrill
8/9/22 12:20pm
Not the best, but sure. And sounds like you just set the example that a zero day notice works too.
TCuz
8/8/22 10:42pm
^^this
JoeExotic
8/8/22 10:48pm
How much notice do employers give employees before layoffs?
Probable Sacko
8/8/22 10:43pm
Amen
Kolobrdm
8/8/22 10:53pm
How much free labor (reverse severance) do employees give after quitting?
Dryfire
8/9/22 8:06am
Yep. Loyalty goes both ways.
Orem58thBall
8/9/22 10:33am
Do you give people you're firing/laying off 2 weeks notice?
cambo
8/8/22 10:48pm
He already answered that as no when he fired her today.
ochobeeguy
8/8/22 10:55pm
Get wrecked bro
Sircumference
8/9/22 6:06am
Do you give 2 weeks notice before a RIF?
CougGolf
8/8/22 10:57pm
What is your business name so I can leave a 2 star on yelp
JoeExotic
8/8/22 11:03pm
RE: What is your business name so I can leave a 2 star on yelp
Bin01015
8/8/22 11:25pm
Not ideal but as a business owner I've always tried to take the high road and avoid burning bridges
BIG XII Coug
8/9/22 8:17am
Same. Plus if it's a good employee, at least I get 4 more days out of him/her while I'm trying to locate a replacement.
unctoothman
8/9/22 8:43am
Utah is a
Lavell4life
8/9/22 1:17am
This is the correct and only answer
BYURider
8/9/22 5:29am
Does Sale live in Utah?
ColonelMustard
8/9/22 11:06am
I thought this was going to be a fill-in-the-blank post about the school up N.
Pangare
8/9/22 11:20am
I just did this a couple months ago.
AZPTCOUG
8/9/22 5:42am
RE: I just let an employee go today for only giving me a one week notice
Cougarnovas
8/8/22 10:41pm
You definitely set precedence.
Bin01015
8/8/22 10:43pm
sweet, just threw your application in the trash lol
Sale
8/8/22 10:46pm
RE: sweet, just threw your application in the trash lol
maxpowers
8/8/22 10:50pm
*precedent
ochobeeguy
8/8/22 10:56pm
Careful, he might fire you for insuportanation
ryebrye
8/9/22 5:50am
RE: Careful, he might fire you for insuportanation
Grammar Police
8/9/22 9:15am
Don’t tell Sale you’re leaving unless you want to be let go the same day.
DieHarder
8/8/22 10:47pm
I had an employer do that once, though I offered two weeks initially.
OPINIONS
8/8/22 10:47pm
Brazilcoug right now..
JohnnyComeLately
8/8/22 10:47pm
Lame. Super lame.
cambo
8/8/22 10:47pm
It’s not uncommon for us to do that even with 2 weeks notice.
ponys
8/8/22 10:48pm
It’s okay for you to terminate her employment without notice but she has some obligation to extend that courtesy to
Pimpin4Paradise
8/8/22 10:49pm
It seems like not too many of you have ever been an employer
Sale
8/8/22 10:55pm
Yes. I’m a hiring manager that not only has a large team of direct reports but a sizable number of second level reports.
Pimpin4Paradise
8/8/22 10:57pm
Feel free to enlighten us then on how employees should notify their employers
Sale
8/8/22 10:59pm
Preferably they’ll provide two weeks. If you’re a good employer, they almost always do. Your behavior of tossing someone
Pimpin4Paradise
8/8/22 11:01pm
Riiight. Way to twist that and make some far-fetched assumptions
Sale
8/8/22 11:03pm
I’ve managed hundreds of different people over the last 15 years. I can only think of one time where an employee quit
Pimpin4Paradise
8/8/22 11:09pm
I think you are missing the point. Yeah it sucks when folks give you a short
Bin01015
8/8/22 11:24pm
Well said for a non-donor
TNT
8/8/22 11:43pm
You're asking for feedback and that is how it looks from the outside. Even if it
ekiben
8/9/22 2:05am
My question is was this a good employee? It seems it got lost in this chest beating session. If the employee was solid a
DJROSS
8/9/22 8:03am
I disagree. A professional approach includes the hiring company saying
BYU Tar Heel
8/9/22 7:38am
"If you’re a good employer, they almost always do" — This is the key here…
ochobeeguy
8/9/22 8:00am
There is no should. They are not legally obligated to provide anything at all. I
here's to hoping
8/9/22 2:45am
Cry me a river
cambo
8/8/22 10:58pm
You sound more and more like someone I wouldn't want to work for.
ochobeeguy
8/8/22 10:58pm
Good and you sound like someone I wouldn't want to hire
Sale
8/8/22 11:03pm
You are going to have a difficult time attracting and holding onto good talent.
JoeExotic
8/8/22 11:06pm
That doesn't seem like a big concern
TNT
8/8/22 11:48pm
Bro, did you post that thinking you’d just get positive feedback?
dixieutahbyuzag
8/9/22 12:39am
He posted it because his policy manual said he had to. The other poster he was
ryebrye
8/9/22 7:58am
I'd never want 2 work for someone who won't hear criticism & just gets defensive
ochobeeguy
8/9/22 8:05am
Why ask the question if you already made up your mind to not accept any negative
Sircumference
8/9/22 10:50am
So your solution was to not even use the notice she did give...? Seems like if
BYUFootballisBack
8/8/22 10:59pm
“You can’t break up with me cuz I break up with you first…”
Pimpin4Paradise
8/8/22 11:02pm
Been a while since we had a CBer pile on OP thread
BYUFootballisBack
8/8/22 11:05pm
RE: Been a while since we had a CBer pile on OP thread
cambo
8/8/22 11:07pm
So you made it harder on yourself with even shorter notice?
YIsForBrigham
8/8/22 11:01pm
I’ll bet you’re in an at-will state and there’s not a word about providing 2
CougGolf
8/8/22 11:01pm
Do you have any idea how challenging it is to be laid off and unemployed with
valleus
8/8/22 11:05pm
So you decided to make it harder on yourself by getting rid of her today?
crazY
8/8/22 11:29pm
It depends on the type of work, if no one can do her job or maybe she had too
SwanSong
8/9/22 12:52am
It's even harder to hire if your company has a bad reputation
ryebrye
8/9/22 5:41am
Right. And former employees who were treated badly will be motivated
Orem58thBall
8/9/22 10:46am
I usually give 2-4 weeks notice…
NonmormonYfan89
8/9/22 5:52am
I love this assumption in these threads. "You disagree with my decision? You
russkiejedi
8/9/22 8:41am
I don’t get why everyone is responding with that. Is t that exactly the case?
ColonelMustard
8/9/22 11:08am
Could you imagine? “I just wanted to let you know that this is your two weeks
BYU Tar Heel
8/9/22 11:20am
I don't think anybody's saying they should give 2 weeks notice before firing
wannnacruise
8/9/22 11:28am
The employer courtesy is severance
BYU Tar Heel
8/9/22 12:14pm
That makes a little more sense. Thank you
ColonelMustard
8/9/22 2:46pm
Is this a reverse or something?
TNT
8/8/22 10:52pm
I had to scroll down and check, assumed I missed something good
wannnacruise
8/8/22 10:56pm
The precedence being that they shouldn't give any notice? Because you'll push them out immediately.
John Doe
8/8/22 10:55pm
There are givers and there are takers
Endocoug
8/8/22 11:01pm
RE: There are givers and there are takers
JollyGreenGiant
8/8/22 11:03pm
What makes you think I did not give her thanks? We parted on good terms and she
Sale
8/8/22 11:06pm
Lame policy. She expresses interest in a year and you won't consider hiring her?
cambo
8/8/22 11:10pm
I can accept that. We probably need to reconsider that
Sale
8/8/22 11:13pm
I was gonna say, boils down to 2 things 1) was she a good employee? If yes the
BYUFootballisBack
8/8/22 11:19pm
Wait, it’s policy to terminate anyone who doesn’t give a 2 week notice?
Endocoug
8/8/22 11:31pm
^THIS. Honestly, I have a hard time believing that. That would be extremely
kos
8/9/22 5:34am
She said I’m the best boss she’s ever seen. Never better.
Soren Tversky
8/9/22 1:10am
Almost everyone leaves on good terms. It's the next day they get pissed once
Jacksonian76
8/9/22 6:53am
Wait, did you want feedback or not? Let me put this a different way,
Pangare
8/9/22 8:07am
Her response to not being re-hirable
Ikuna
8/9/22 3:13pm
That is super insecure to run business like that.
JoeExotic
8/8/22 11:12pm
Some employers abuse the two-weeks notice thing and let employees go the moment
garyfan
8/8/22 11:27pm
I would never do that. I would honor the 2 week notice so long as the employee
Sale
8/8/22 11:32pm
But your employees just saw you tell one of their colleagues to pack her bags.
garyfan
8/8/22 11:38pm
I agree with this. Also, he likely put more work on the other employees in the short term. I don't think it was wise.
jdub
8/9/22 12:11am
RE: I agree with this. Also, he likely put more work on the other employees in
garyfan
8/9/22 12:16am
This is the biggest thing - if I'm his employee, I'm now less likely to give ANY notice
krindorr
8/9/22 3:33am
What kind of team do you manage?
NonmormonYfan89
8/9/22 6:02am
"I would never do that"…but if it were 1 week, all bets are off…
ochobeeguy
8/9/22 10:32am
It amazes me how one sided some people are…
delbert
8/8/22 11:32pm
This ^^^, plus we honestly didn’t get enough info about the job, industry, etc
babycarrot
8/9/22 2:08am
Letting her go 4 days early is nbd
JoeExotic
8/9/22 5:19am
Therefore, her leaving 5 days early is also nbd.
Les IsMore
8/9/22 9:35am
Well thought out and written post.
rerunc
8/9/22 6:05am
I think the part you're missing is he is not helping himself out AT ALL
ryebrye
8/9/22 6:16am
This is the right answer. He’s hurting himself in both the short run and
Joe
8/10/22 4:59am
It’s a one-sided thing. There’s really no sense in which this wasn’t a bad
russkiejedi
8/9/22 10:31am
It's not 4 days, it's 5, and it was totally done in spite.
ochobeeguy
8/9/22 10:34am
If you’re in an at-will employment state, no issues
kapcreations
8/8/22 11:45pm
This is correct.
rainorsnow
8/9/22 6:10pm
Thanks everyone for taking the time to share your thoughts. Helps me
Sale
8/8/22 11:48pm
It really depends on the employee. I try not to burn bridges unless the employee
BNcoug
8/9/22 12:17am
You started off so strong, but then had to throw in the bit about victimhood.
Joe
8/10/22 5:37am
RE: I just let an employee go today for only giving me a one week notice
Sid Vicious
8/9/22 12:23am
In the past, I've had a job....
trigg3r
8/9/22 1:34am
First. You had the stones to come here and disclose a leadership decision and
JarJarBeeps
8/9/22 1:42am
Here’s what you should do tomorrow:
garyfan
8/9/22 2:27am
After reading this thread, there is zero chance he's going to do that.
ryebrye
8/9/22 5:45am
This
JarJarBeeps
8/9/22 9:11am
A thousand times, this.
Mitty
8/9/22 10:04am
My question for you on how things played out..
WY_CougFan
8/9/22 2:43am
^ this
mobicurious
8/9/22 4:57am
I think the important question is did you pay her for the rest of the week?
NYC and Japan
8/9/22 7:37am
Throughout this whole thread, there seems to be a common element missing
Acorn
8/9/22 5:48am
Last paragraph spot on.
rerunc
8/9/22 6:10am
<< Deleted >>
Ozymandias
8/9/22 6:20am
I would think that if accrued vacation was a documented benefit, the employee would be entitled to it no matter what.
Rhino84
8/9/22 7:50am
Depending on company policy and state regulation you may have to pay that out
Dr T-bone
8/9/22 7:54am
I know this is a slightly different topic but in our company they limit carry-over of accrued time off (year to year)
Rhino84
8/9/22 8:03am
For my last job, I only gave one weeks notice. I spent the year prior dealing
LaserCoug
8/9/22 6:29am
Do you give employees a two week notice?
Les IsMore
8/9/22 6:57am
<< Deleted >>
The_ATL
8/9/22 7:10am
Is she under contract to give 2 weeks? Otherwise it’s not a requirnent BUT if
Dr MoBYU
8/9/22 7:14am
I love how the OP is questioning whether he did it correctly and when everyone
Ozymandias
8/9/22 7:15am
"I'm a people person!"
ryebrye
8/9/22 7:50am
Does she still get her PTO paid out since she didn’t stay for the two weeks?
Magneto
8/9/22 7:18am
Dumb move. By firing her you just opened up the door for her to get unemployment
Short_Changed
8/9/22 7:26am
In the past I have normally begged my employees to stay an extra week to get us
gww687
8/9/22 7:34am
I gave a two weeks notice once too…..
SaintJeff
8/9/22 7:39am
Perfectly fine if their next employment violates a no competition clause. I've
NewMexiCoug
8/9/22 7:52am
How dare you not berate him like everyone else on CB!
ColonelMustard
8/9/22 11:18am
There are situations where it's appropriate to cut off departing employees
Roko's Basilisk
8/9/22 7:56am
This thread belongs on r/antiwork. Sale would be eaten alive by the proletariat.
beatnik
8/9/22 7:57am
NO, they must give longer notice, but you don't. Is that fair?
Count Cougar
8/9/22 7:59am
Now you'll have to pay unemployment (because fired vs. resigning). Not worth it.
bluebooks
8/9/22 8:04am
depends on the state laws
Pangare
8/9/22 8:09am
Just don’t expect anyone else to give you any notice at all.
Mot
8/9/22 8:08am
Without enough information about this employees work record and relationship to the company it would be difficult to say
DJROSS
8/9/22 8:18am
Co-workers took notice. They now will give zero days notice.
flyzag
8/9/22 8:55am
To all those saying that other employees will now just give 0 days notice,
babycarrot
8/9/22 10:23am
huh?
Northwest Cougar
8/9/22 10:31am
I acknowledged that point but gave my reason for why I don’t think that pertains
babycarrot
8/9/22 10:47am
I just don't see any scenario where you give 0 days notice but don't get paid
Northwest Cougar
8/9/22 11:23am
I guess what I meant is the following:
babycarrot
8/9/22 11:35am
I think Sale knows his business better than any of us do. That sort of thing is
Thrill
8/9/22 11:33am
Then why did he come ask CB about it?
kos
8/9/22 12:15pm
Evidence is inconclusive.
Les IsMore
8/9/22 1:30pm
This sounds like when Michael Scott fired fat Tony instead of letting him quit
chrisrenrut
8/9/22 12:05pm
Really stupid move. NOW she can claim…
byubananastand
8/9/22 2:12pm
Most states have a qualifying period. If she has a job lined up, she'll be fine
LaserCoug
8/9/22 2:18pm
If her job offer gets rescinded, he’s wide open to it.
byubananastand
8/9/22 2:20pm
To answer your question, no you did not do it right and you sound bad as a boss
Ikuna
8/9/22 3:08pm
RE: fired almost immediately for not giving 2 weeks notice - sure sounds..
greatbam
8/9/22 3:25pm
This won't set precedent. Unprofessional people that would have failed to give
ekiben
8/9/22 8:47pm
Don’t bring me into this
JL31
8/9/22 11:28pm
Depends on the position and comp structure imo
JL31
8/9/22 11:38pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad